Pai Chung-Yen, Hsieh Ling-Ling, Lee Tzu-Cheng, Yang Shi-Bing, Linville Jason, Chou Su-Lien, Yang Chiou-Herr
Department of Forensic Sciences, Central Police University, 56 Shu-Jen Road, Kueishan, Taoyuan 33334, Taiwan.
Forensic Sci Int. 2006 Jan 27;156(2-3):124-30. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2004.12.021.
There are hundreds of millions of betel quid (BQ) lovers widely spreading around the world. Compositions in BQ may generate reactive oxygen species, which would induce DNA damage. However, oral epithelial cells as well as blood have often been used as reference samples in comparison with the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence of hairs. The main purpose of this study was to investigate the extent of mtDNA sequence variation in regular BQ-chewers' oral epithelial cells, and thus to evaluate the forensic availability of the buccal cells from BQ-chewers using the mtDNA markers. The hypervariable segments I and II in the D-loop control region of mtDNA between paired samples of blood and buccal scrape cells from 75 non-BQ-chewers (to be a control group), 60 BQ-chewers, and 67 oral cancerous patients were DNA sequenced and compared. Among the three groups, the alteration rates of 1.3% (1 out of 75), 10% (6 out of 60), and 61% (41 out of 67) were identified from the control, BQ-chewers, and the cancerous group, respectively. In the cancerous group, as expected, high rate of DNA alteration between blood and buccal samples was found. In the BQ-chewers, one and five individuals had the length and point alterations, respectively. Interestingly, most of point alteration sites, e.g., mtDNA positions 153, 16189, 16093 identified from BQ-chewers, were also observed in previous literatures. As for the control subjects, one case with point alteration, and none with length alteration, was identified. For all the three groups, not only the oral cells but also the normal blood samples exhibited high frequency (>55%) of length heteroplasmy at poly-(C)n track. Statistical analyses revealed that significance was observed between the severity of mtDNA alteration in BQ-chewers' oral epithelial cells and the history of BQ-chewing (p = 0.02), with a tendency of positive association. Based on the guidelines by Carracedo et al., we suggest that the interpretation of mtDNA variations between criminal evidences and the oral epithelial cells (as a reference or known sample) from BQ-chewers should be performed with particular caution using the PCR-based mtDNA sequencing. Our findings would be valuable in mtDNA analysis of hair evidence, especially for those countries where the habit of BQ-chewing is popular.
全球有数亿槟榔爱好者。槟榔中的成分可能产生活性氧,进而导致DNA损伤。然而,口腔上皮细胞和血液常被用作与毛发线粒体DNA(mtDNA)序列进行比较的参考样本。本研究的主要目的是调查经常咀嚼槟榔者口腔上皮细胞中mtDNA序列变异的程度,从而利用mtDNA标记评估咀嚼槟榔者颊细胞的法医可用性。对75名非咀嚼槟榔者(作为对照组)、60名咀嚼槟榔者和67名口腔癌患者的配对血液样本和颊部刮取细胞样本中mtDNA的D环控制区高变区I和II进行DNA测序并比较。在这三组中,对照组、咀嚼槟榔组和癌症组的改变率分别为1.3%(75例中的1例)、10%(60例中的6例)和61%(67例中的41例)。在癌症组中,正如预期的那样,发现血液和颊部样本之间的DNA改变率很高。在咀嚼槟榔者中,分别有1人和5人发生了长度改变和点突变。有趣的是,从咀嚼槟榔者中鉴定出的大多数点突变位点,如mtDNA位置153、16189、16093,在以往文献中也有观察到。对于对照组受试者,鉴定出1例点突变病例,未发现长度改变病例。对于所有三组,不仅口腔细胞,而且正常血液样本在聚(C)n序列处均表现出高频率(>55%)的长度异质性。统计分析显示,咀嚼槟榔者口腔上皮细胞中mtDNA改变的严重程度与咀嚼槟榔史之间存在显著差异(p = 0.02),呈正相关趋势。根据Carracedo等人的指导方针,我们建议在使用基于PCR的mtDNA测序对犯罪证据与咀嚼槟榔者的口腔上皮细胞(作为参考或已知样本)之间的mtDNA变异进行解释时应格外谨慎。我们的研究结果对于毛发证据的mtDNA分析具有重要价值,特别是对于那些咀嚼槟榔习惯盛行国家。