Orton S L, Stramer S L, Dodd R Y
Division of Blood Applications, FDA, CBER, OBRR, Rockville, Maryland, USA.
Transfusion. 2006 Feb;46(2):272-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1537-2995.2006.00710.x.
In 2003, West Nile virus (WNV) nucleic acid amplification testing (NAT) was implemented to detect potentially infected donors. Of more than 5.3 million donations screened prospectively by the American Red Cross during the epidemic periods of 2003 and 2004, 974 were NAT-reactive and 519 confirmed-positive. A subset of both the confirmed-positive and the false-positive groups was assessed for demographic characteristics, symptoms, and symptom reporting relative to date of donation.
All donors with initial WNV NAT-reactive results were invited to participate in a study that included a demographic, symptom, and date-of-symptom questionnaire. WNV confirmed-positive cases were compared to false-positive controls for comparison of frequency of symptom reporting before, on the day of, and after donation.
Enrolled cases and controls were similar in all characteristics except cases were more likely to live in rural areas. Symptoms were reported by 61 percent of cases versus 20 percent of controls, with 74 percent of symptoms reported by cases within the 14 days after donation. The frequency of headache and fever reported together in the 7 days before donation was not significantly different between cases and controls; only the individual frequencies of headache, eye pain, and new rash during this time were significantly different. The most commonly reported symptoms, after adjustment for symptom reporting by controls, were headache, new rash, and generalized weakness; these symptoms were reported by 25 percent of cases.
The demographic characteristics of infected donors reflected the rural nature of the 2003 to 2004 WNV epidemics. This study suggests that asking donors about predonation headache and fever had no detectable contribution to blood safety.
2003年,实施了西尼罗河病毒(WNV)核酸扩增检测(NAT)以检测潜在感染的献血者。在2003年和2004年疫情期间,美国红十字会对超过530万份献血进行了前瞻性筛查,其中974份NAT检测呈阳性反应,519份确诊为阳性。对确诊阳性组和假阳性组的一个子集进行了人口统计学特征、症状以及与献血日期相关的症状报告评估。
所有初次WNV NAT检测呈阳性反应的献血者均受邀参加一项研究,该研究包括一份人口统计学、症状及症状出现日期的问卷。将WNV确诊阳性病例与假阳性对照进行比较,以对比献血前、献血当日及献血后症状报告的频率。
入组的病例和对照在所有特征方面均相似,只是病例更有可能居住在农村地区。61%的病例报告了症状,而对照中这一比例为20%,74%的病例症状报告发生在献血后的14天内。病例组和对照组在献血前7天同时报告头痛和发热的频率无显著差异;仅在此期间头痛、眼痛和新发皮疹的个体频率存在显著差异。在对对照的症状报告进行调整后,最常报告的症状为头痛、新发皮疹和全身乏力;25%的病例报告了这些症状。
受感染献血者的人口统计学特征反映了2003年至2004年WNV疫情的农村性质。本研究表明,询问献血者献血前的头痛和发热情况对血液安全无明显贡献。