Addy M, Sharif N, Moran J
Division of Restorative Dentistry, Dental School, Bristol, UK.
Int J Dent Hyg. 2005 May;3(2):59-63. doi: 10.1111/j.1601-5037.2005.00117.x.
Tooth staining is a common side effect of chlorhexidine mouth rinses and caused by the interaction of the di-cationic antiseptic with dietary chromogens. A product is now available, which claims an anti-discolouration system (ADS) with one clinical study in support. This study in vitro aims to determine whether two ADS rinses do or do not bind dietary chromogens.
Optically clear acrylic specimens were cycled through human saliva (2 min), one of the three chlorhexidine rinses (two ADS and a positive control) (2 min) or water and then soaked in tea (60 min). After each cycle the optical density (OD) of specimens were read on a UV/visible spectrophotometer. The exit point was the cycle at which OD was >2.0.
All three rinses exceeded OD 2 at 11 cycles and there was no significant difference in staining for the ADS rinses compared with the positive control rinse.
Based on extensive literature for the correlation of this test in vitro with chlorhexidine anti-plaque activity and propensity to stain in vivo these ADS rinses will have the same anti-plaque efficacy and potential to cause stain as established chlorhexidine rinse products.
牙齿染色是洗必泰漱口水常见的副作用,由二价阳离子防腐剂与食物色素相互作用引起。现在有一种产品,宣称具有防变色系统(ADS),并有一项临床研究作为支撑。本体外研究旨在确定两种含ADS的漱口水是否会结合食物色素。
将光学透明的丙烯酸标本依次置于人唾液(2分钟)、三种洗必泰漱口水之一(两种含ADS的漱口水和一种阳性对照)(2分钟)或水中,然后浸泡在茶中(60分钟)。每个循环后,在紫外/可见分光光度计上读取标本的光密度(OD)。终止点为OD大于2.0的循环。
所有三种漱口水在11个循环时OD均超过2,与阳性对照漱口水相比,含ADS的漱口水在染色方面无显著差异。
基于大量关于该体外试验与洗必泰抗牙菌斑活性及体内染色倾向相关性的文献,这些含ADS的漱口水与已有的洗必泰漱口水产品具有相同的抗牙菌斑功效和导致染色的可能性。