Barrichelo Viviane M O, Behlau Mara
Centro de Estudos da Voz, São Paulo, Brazil.
J Voice. 2007 Jan;21(1):46-53. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2005.08.014. Epub 2006 Feb 2.
This study aimed to verify whether the resonant voice based on Lessac's Y-Buzz can be perceived by listeners as resonant and different from habitual voice and to compare them to determine whether this sound exploration improves the vocal production. Nine newly graduated actors, six men and three women without voice complaints, were the subjects. They received a session of Lessac's Y-Buzz training from the primary investigator. Before training, they were asked to sustain the vowel /i/ at comfortable frequency and habitual loudness. After training, they were requested to sustain the Y-Buzz they had learned at a comfortable frequency and habitual loudness. Three speech-language pathologists (SLP) trained in voice developed an auditory-perceptive analysis. The pre- and posttraining voice samples were randomly spliced together, edited, and presented in pairs to perceptual judges who were asked to identify the most resonant of the pair. The voice samples were also acoustically compared through the Hoarseness Diagram and acoustic measures using the VoxMetria Software (CTS, version 2.0s, Brazil). The Y-Buzz trials were identified as resonant voice in 74% of the comparisons. The acoustic measures showed a statistically significant decrease of irregularity (P = 0.002) and shimmer (P = 0.38). The Hoarseness Diagram demonstrated how the resonant voice moved toward the normality for irregularity and noise components. The results showed that the resonant voice based on the Y-Buzz can be identified as resonant and different from normal voicing in the same subject, and it apparently implies a better vocal production demonstrating a significant decrease of shimmer and irregularity through the Hoarseness Diagram evaluation.
本研究旨在验证基于莱萨克氏Y音的共鸣嗓音是否能被听众感知为具有共鸣且与习惯性嗓音不同,并对二者进行比较以确定这种发声探索是否能改善发声。九名刚毕业的演员作为受试者,其中六名男性和三名女性,均无嗓音问题。他们接受了来自第一作者的莱萨克氏Y音训练课程。训练前,要求他们以舒适的频率和习惯性响度持续发元音/i/。训练后,要求他们以舒适的频率和习惯性响度持续发所学的Y音。三名接受过嗓音训练的言语治疗师进行了听觉感知分析。训练前和训练后的嗓音样本被随机拼接、编辑,然后成对呈现给感知评判者,要求他们识别出每对样本中最具共鸣的声音。嗓音样本还通过嘶哑图和使用VoxMetria软件(CTS,2.0s版本,巴西)的声学测量进行声学比较。在74%的比较中,Y音试验被识别为共鸣嗓音。声学测量显示不规则度(P = 0.002)和微颤(P = 0.38)在统计学上有显著下降。嘶哑图展示了共鸣嗓音在不规则度和噪声成分方面如何向正常状态转变。结果表明,基于Y音的共鸣嗓音可被识别为具有共鸣且与同一受试者的正常发声不同,并且通过嘶哑图评估显示微颤和不规则度显著下降,这显然意味着发声得到了改善。