Swanepoel De Wet, Hugo René, Louw Brenda
Department of Communication Pathology, University of Pretoria, Pretoria 0002, South Africa.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2006 Jul;70(7):1241-9. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2006.01.002. Epub 2006 Feb 14.
Benefits of early identification and subsequent intervention for hearing loss are not accessible to infants in developing countries like South Africa. There are no systematic screening programs and traditional platforms for newborn hearing screening, such as well-baby and intensive care nurseries, do not provide sufficient coverage due to the high incidence of births at home or in primary healthcare facilities. Primary healthcare structures, in the form of immunization clinics, have been proposed as an alternative screening platform. The current study, therefore, investigates a hearing screening program implemented at two immunization clinics in a representative South African community.
The two clinics in the current study were selected by a convenience sampling method in a community representative of large sections of the population. The hearing screening program was conducted over a 5-month period, and enrolled 510 infants (0-12 months of age). The screening protocol included Distortion Product Oto-Acoustic Emissions (DPOAE) and a high frequency probe tone (1000 Hz) tympanogram. Referral was based on one or both ears referring the DPOAE screen. Follow-up screening and diagnostic evaluations were scheduled for referred subjects.
Coverage with DPOAE amounted to 95% of the sample ears (93% of sample subjects) compared to tympanogram coverage amounting to 94% (93% of sample subjects). OAE pass rates were 93% for the sample ears with neonatal ears indicating a higher pass rate of 95% compared to 92% for infant ears (5-52 weeks of age). Eighty-seven percent of the sample ears indicated peaked tympanograms indicative of normal middle-ear functioning and neonatal ears presented with an increased incidence of peaked tympanograms (92%). A highly significant association between the DPOAE and high frequency tympanometric result was found. Follow-up screening appointments were scheduled for 68 subjects (14% of screened sample). Only 40% returned for the second follow-up and 44% for the third follow-up.
Immunization clinics indicate promise as infant hearing screening platforms, but identification of only bilateral hearing losses may be warranted initially to keep referral rates acceptably low. In addition to this efficient tracking systems are necessary to ensure acceptably high follow-up return rates are reached over time.
在南非这样的发展中国家,婴儿无法从早期识别及后续听力损失干预中获益。不存在系统的筛查项目,且新生儿听力筛查的传统平台,如母婴保健室和重症监护病房,因在家中或初级医疗保健机构分娩的发生率高而覆盖率不足。有人提议将免疫接种门诊形式的初级医疗保健机构作为替代筛查平台。因此,本研究调查了在南非一个具有代表性社区的两家免疫接种门诊实施的听力筛查项目。
本研究中的两家门诊是通过便利抽样法在一个代表大部分人口的社区中选取的。听力筛查项目为期5个月,纳入了510名婴儿(0至12个月大)。筛查方案包括畸变产物耳声发射(DPOAE)和高频探测音(1000赫兹)鼓室图。转诊基于一耳或双耳DPOAE筛查结果异常。为转诊对象安排了后续筛查和诊断评估。
DPOAE的覆盖率为样本耳的95%(样本对象的93%),而鼓室图的覆盖率为94%(样本对象的93%)。样本耳的OAE通过率为93%,新生儿耳的通过率更高,为95%,而婴儿耳(5至52周龄)的通过率为92%。87%的样本耳鼓室图呈尖峰状,表明中耳功能正常,新生儿耳鼓室图呈尖峰状的发生率更高(92%)。发现DPOAE与高频鼓室图结果之间存在高度显著的关联。为68名对象(筛查样本的14%)安排了后续筛查预约。第二次随访只有40%的人返回,第三次随访只有44%的人返回。
免疫接种门诊有望成为婴儿听力筛查平台,但最初可能仅需识别双侧听力损失,以使转诊率保持在可接受的低水平。此外,需要有效的追踪系统,以确保随着时间推移达到可接受的高随访返回率。