Mackey William C, Fleisher Lee A, Haider Seema, Sheikh Saraih, Cappelleri Joseph C, Lee Won Chan, Wang Qin, Stephens Jennifer M
Department of Surgery, Tufts-New England Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts 02111, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 2006 Mar;43(3):533-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2005.11.013.
The purpose of this study was to assess prospectively the incidence, health care resource utilization, and economic burden associated with perioperative myocardial ischemic injury (PMII) in high-risk patients undergoing noncardiac vascular surgery.
Two hundred thirty-six patients consented to participate in a pharmacoeconomic substudy as part of a randomized, multicenter clinical trial. Patients were assessed for myocardial ischemic injury by using clinical, biochemical, and electrocardiographic criteria. PMII was defined as fatal or nonfatal myocardial infarction, new or worsened congestive heart failure, or new arrhythmias. Resource utilization parameters were compared for patients with and without PMII. Patients underwent the following index procedures: open abdominal aortic aneurysm repair (n = 44), bypass for aortoiliac disease (n = 29), bypass for femoropopliteal disease (n = 62), bypass for femorotibial disease (n = 71), extra-anatomic bypass (n = 23), and miscellaneous (n = 7). Patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy or only endovascular interventions were excluded. The incremental cost of PMII was estimated by applying the average costs (adjusted to 2004 US dollars) of the hospital ward (dollar 700.00/d) or intensive care unit (dollar 2500.00/d) to the length of stay differences for patients with and without PMII.
The overall mortality was 3.4% (8/236), and 7 of 8 deaths were related to PMII. PMII occurred in 42 (17.8%) of 236 patients: 22 myocardial infarctions, 11 congestive heart failures, and 12 new arrhythmias (3 patients had 2 PMII events). There was no evidence of differences in the incidence of PMII among the various index procedures. PMII was associated with a dramatic increase in resource utilization. The mean length of stay was 16.8 and 10.0 days for patients with and without PMII, respectively (P < .001). Intensive care unit care was required by 35 (83.3%) of 42 patients with and 121 (62.4%) of 194 patients without PMII (P < .009). The mean intensive care unit length of stay was 6.6 and 3.7 days for patients with and without PMII, respectively (P < .009). Ten (23.8%) of 42 patients with and 20 (10.3%) of 194 patients without PMII returned to the emergency department for care after discharge (P < .02).
In modern vascular surgery practice, PMII remains common despite the availability of beta-blockers and other preventative strategies. PMII is associated with dramatic increases in resource utilization and cost. The increase in resource utilization associated with PMII resulted in an estimated incremental cost per patient of dollar 9980.00. If 250,000 high-risk open vascular operations are performed annually in the United States, the economic burden of PMII in these procedures alone approximates dollar 444 million. Strategies to decrease PMII incidence and severity should be evaluated in large-scale prospective trials.
本研究旨在前瞻性评估接受非心脏血管手术的高危患者围手术期心肌缺血损伤(PMII)的发生率、医疗资源利用情况及经济负担。
236例患者同意参与一项药物经济学子研究,该研究是一项随机、多中心临床试验的一部分。采用临床、生化及心电图标准评估患者的心肌缺血损伤情况。PMII定义为致命或非致命性心肌梗死、新发或加重的充血性心力衰竭或新发心律失常。比较发生和未发生PMII患者的资源利用参数。患者接受以下指数手术:腹主动脉瘤开放修复术(n = 44)、主髂动脉疾病搭桥术(n = 29)、股腘动脉疾病搭桥术(n = 62)、股胫动脉疾病搭桥术(n = 71)、解剖外搭桥术(n = 23)及其他手术(n = 7)。接受颈动脉内膜切除术或仅接受血管内介入治疗的患者被排除。通过将医院病房(700.00美元/天)或重症监护病房(2500.00美元/天)的平均费用(调整为2004年美元)应用于发生和未发生PMII患者的住院天数差异,估算PMII的增量成本。
总死亡率为3.4%(8/236),8例死亡中有7例与PMII相关。236例患者中有42例(17.8%)发生PMII:22例心肌梗死、11例充血性心力衰竭和12例新发心律失常(3例患者发生2次PMII事件)。各指数手术之间PMII发生率无差异。PMII与资源利用显著增加相关。发生和未发生PMII患者的平均住院天数分别为16.8天和10.0天(P <.001)。42例发生PMII患者中有35例(83.3%)、194例未发生PMII患者中有121例(62.4%)需要重症监护病房护理(P <.009)。发生和未发生PMII患者的平均重症监护病房住院天数分别为6.6天和3.7天(P <.009)。42例发生PMII患者中有10例(23.8%)、194例未发生PMII患者中有20例(10.3%)出院后返回急诊科接受治疗(P <.02)。
在现代血管外科实践中,尽管有β受体阻滞剂和其他预防策略,PMII仍然常见。PMII与资源利用和成本的显著增加相关。与PMII相关的资源利用增加导致每位患者的估计增量成本为9980.00美元。如果美国每年进行250,000例高危开放性血管手术,仅这些手术中PMII的经济负担就接近4.44亿美元。应在大规模前瞻性试验中评估降低PMII发生率和严重程度的策略。