Slomine Beth S, McCarthy Melissa L, Ding Ru, MacKenzie Ellen J, Jaffe Kenneth M, Aitken Mary E, Durbin Dennis R, Christensen James R, Dorsch Andrea M, Paidas Charles N
Department of Neuropsychology, Kennedy Krieger Institute, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Pediatrics. 2006 Apr;117(4):e663-74. doi: 10.1542/peds.2005-1892. Epub 2006 Mar 13.
Children with moderate to severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) show early neurobehavioral deficits that can persist several years after injury. Despite the negative impact that TBI can have on a child's physical, cognitive, and psychosocial well-being, only 1 study to date has documented the receipt of health care services after acute care and the needs of children after TBI. The purpose of this study was to document the health care use and needs of children after a TBI and to identify factors that are associated with unmet or unrecognized health care needs during the first year after injury.
The health care use and needs of children who sustained a TBI were obtained via telephone interview with a primary caregiver at 2 and 12 months after injury. Of the 330 who enrolled in the study, 302 (92%) completed the 3-month and 288 (87%) completed the 12-month follow-up interviews. The health care needs of each child were categorized as no need, met need, unmet need, or unrecognized need on the basis of the child's use of post-acute services, the caregiver's report of unmet need, and the caregiver's report of the child's functioning as measured by the Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory (PedsQL). Regardless of the use of services or level of function, children of caregivers who reported an unmet need for a health care service were defined as having unmet need. Children who were categorized as having no needs were defined as those who did not receive services; whose caregiver did not report unmet need for a service; and the whose physical, socioemotional, and cognitive functioning was reported to be normal by the caregiver. Children with met needs were those who used services in a particular domain and whose caregivers did not report need for additional services. Finally, children with unrecognized needs were those whose caregiver reported cognitive, physical, or socioemotional dysfunction; who were not receiving services to address the dysfunction; and whose caregiver did not report unmet need for services. Polytomous logistic regression was used to model unmet and unrecognized need at 3 and 12 months after injury as a function of child, family, and injury characteristics.
At 3 months after injury, 62% of the study sample reported receiving at least 1 outpatient health care service. Most frequently, children visited a doctor (56%) or a physical therapist (27%); however, 37% of caregivers reported that their child did not see a physician at all during the first year after injury. At 3 and 12 months after injury, 26% and 31% of children, respectively, had unmet/unrecognized health care needs. The most frequent type of unmet or unrecognized need was for cognitive services. The top 3 reasons for unmet need at 3 and 12 months were (1) not recommended by doctor (34% and 31%); (2) not recommended/provided by school (16% and 17%); and (3) cost too much (16% and 16%). Factors that were associated with unmet or unrecognized need changed over time. At 3 months after injury, the caregivers of children with a preexisting psychosocial condition were 3 times more likely to report unmet need compared with children who did not have one. Also, female caregivers were significantly more likely to report unmet need compared with male caregivers. Finally, the caregivers of children with Medicaid were almost 2 times more likely to report unmet need compared with children who were covered by commercial insurance. The only factor that was associated with unrecognized need at 3 months after injury was abnormal family functioning. At 12 months after injury, although TBI severity was not significant, children who sustained a major associated injury were 2 times more likely to report unmet need compared with children who did not. Consistent with the 3-month results, the caregivers of children with Medicaid were significantly more likely to report unmet needs at 1 year after injury. In addition to poor family functioning's being associated with unrecognized need, nonwhite children were significantly more likely to have unrecognized needs at 1 year compared with white children.
A substantial proportion of children with TBI had unmet or unrecognized health care needs during the first year after injury. It is recommended that pediatricians be involved in the post-acute care follow-up of children with TBI to ensure that the injured child's needs are being addressed in a timely and appropriate manner. One of the recommendations that trauma center providers should make on hospital discharge is that the parent/primary caregiver schedule a visit with the child's pediatrician regardless of the post-acute services that the child may be receiving. Because unmet and unrecognized need was highest for cognitive services, it is important to screen for cognitive dysfunction in the primary care setting. Finally, because the health care needs of children with TBI change over time, it is important for pediatricians to monitor their recovery to ensure that children with TBI receive the services that they need to restore their health after injury.
中重度创伤性脑损伤(TBI)患儿表现出早期神经行为缺陷,这些缺陷可能在受伤后持续数年。尽管TBI会对儿童的身体、认知和社会心理福祉产生负面影响,但迄今为止只有一项研究记录了急性护理后儿童接受的医疗保健服务以及TBI后儿童的需求。本研究的目的是记录TBI后儿童的医疗保健使用情况和需求,并确定与受伤后第一年未满足或未被认识到的医疗保健需求相关的因素。
通过在受伤后2个月和12个月对主要照顾者进行电话访谈,获取TBI患儿的医疗保健使用情况和需求。在参与研究的330名儿童中,302名(92%)完成了3个月的随访访谈,288名(87%)完成了12个月的随访访谈。根据儿童对急性后期服务的使用情况、照顾者报告的未满足需求以及照顾者报告的通过儿童生活质量量表(PedsQL)衡量的儿童功能,将每个儿童的医疗保健需求分为无需求、需求得到满足、需求未得到满足或需求未被认识到。无论服务使用情况或功能水平如何,报告对医疗保健服务有未满足需求的照顾者所照顾的儿童被定义为有未满足需求。被归类为无需求的儿童被定义为未接受服务的儿童;其照顾者未报告对某项服务的未满足需求;且照顾者报告其身体、社会情感和认知功能正常的儿童。需求得到满足的儿童是那些在特定领域使用了服务且其照顾者未报告需要额外服务的儿童。最后,需求未被认识到的儿童是那些其照顾者报告有认知、身体或社会情感功能障碍;未接受针对该功能障碍的服务;且其照顾者未报告对服务有未满足需求的儿童。采用多分类逻辑回归模型,将受伤后3个月和12个月的未满足需求和未被认识到的需求作为儿童、家庭和损伤特征的函数进行建模。
受伤后3个月,62%的研究样本报告至少接受了1次门诊医疗保健服务。最常见的是,儿童看医生(56%)或物理治疗师(27%);然而,37%的照顾者报告他们的孩子在受伤后的第一年根本没有看过医生。受伤后3个月和12个月,分别有26%和31%的儿童有未满足/未被认识到的医疗保健需求。最常见的未满足或未被认识到的需求类型是认知服务。3个月和12个月时未满足需求的前三大原因是:(1)医生未推荐(34%和31%);(2)学校未推荐/提供(16%和17%);(3)费用太高(16%和16%)。与未满足或未被认识到的需求相关的因素随时间而变化。受伤后3个月,有既往社会心理状况的儿童的照顾者报告未满足需求的可能性是没有该状况的儿童的3倍。此外,女性照顾者报告未满足需求的可能性显著高于男性照顾者。最后,与参加商业保险的儿童相比,有医疗补助的儿童的照顾者报告未满足需求的可能性几乎高出2倍。受伤后3个月与未被认识到的需求相关的唯一因素是家庭功能异常。受伤后12个月,尽管TBI严重程度不显著,但遭受重大相关损伤的儿童报告未满足需求的可能性是未遭受此类损伤的儿童的2倍。与3个月时的结果一致,受伤后1年有医疗补助的儿童的照顾者报告未满足需求的可能性显著更高。除了家庭功能不良与未被认识到的需求相关外,与白人儿童相比,非白人儿童在1岁时更有可能有未被认识到的需求。
相当一部分TBI患儿在受伤后的第一年有未满足或未被认识到的医疗保健需求。建议儿科医生参与TBI患儿的急性后期护理随访,以确保受伤儿童的需求得到及时和适当的满足。创伤中心提供者在患儿出院时应提出的一项建议是,无论患儿可能接受何种急性后期服务,家长/主要照顾者都应为患儿安排与儿科医生的就诊。由于认知服务的未满足和未被认识到的需求最高,在初级保健环境中筛查认知功能障碍很重要。最后,由于TBI患儿的医疗保健需求随时间变化,儿科医生监测他们的康复情况很重要,以确保TBI患儿获得受伤后恢复健康所需的服务。