Drizo Aleksandra, Forget Christiane, Chapuis Robert P, Comeau Yves
University of Vermont, Department of Plant and Soil Science, 105 Carrigan Drive, Burlington, VT 05405, USA.
Water Res. 2006 May;40(8):1547-54. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2006.02.001. Epub 2006 Mar 27.
Electric arc furnace (EAF) steel slag and serpentinite were tested in columns either alone or mixed with limestone to determine their capacity to remove phosphorus (P) from a solution containing initially 20mg P/L (for 114 days) than 400mg P/L (for 21 days). EAF steel slag was nearly 100% efficient due to specific P adsorption onto metal hydroxides and precipitation of hydroxyapatite. Serpentinite also showed a good performance that decreased with time, adsorption appearing to be the dominant mechanism for P removal. Mixing limestone with these two materials did not improve their performance and in the case of serpentinite, it actually even decreased it. In 114 days of experimentation, serpentinite alone and the mixture of serpentinite and limestone removed 1.0mg P/g while in 180 days of experimentation, EAF steel slag and the mixture of slag and limestone removed an average of 2.2mg P/g, without attaining their maximum P removal potential. The void hydraulic retention time (HRTv) was a key factor for growing hydroxyapatite crystals and had a significant effect on P removal efficiency by EAF steel slag. A temporary increase in HRTv caused by clogging resulted in an increase in EAF steel slag efficiency (from 80% to almost 100%) towards the end of investigation. Results from this study indicate that the use of EAF steel slag in constructed wetlands or filter beds is a promising solution for P removal via adsorption and precipitation mechanisms.
对电弧炉(EAF)钢渣和蛇纹石进行了柱试验,它们单独使用或与石灰石混合使用,以确定其从初始含磷量为20mg P/L(持续114天)和400mg P/L(持续21天)的溶液中去除磷(P)的能力。由于磷特异性吸附到金属氢氧化物上以及羟基磷灰石沉淀,电弧炉钢渣的去除效率接近100%。蛇纹石也表现出良好的性能,但随时间下降,吸附似乎是去除磷的主要机制。将石灰石与这两种材料混合并没有提高它们的性能,对于蛇纹石而言,实际上甚至降低了其性能。在114天的实验中,单独的蛇纹石以及蛇纹石与石灰石的混合物去除了1.0mg P/g,而在180天的实验中,电弧炉钢渣以及钢渣与石灰石的混合物平均去除了2.2mg P/g,但未达到其最大除磷潜力。孔隙水力停留时间(HRTv)是羟基磷灰石晶体生长的关键因素,对电弧炉钢渣的除磷效率有显著影响。由堵塞导致的HRTv暂时增加,在研究结束时使电弧炉钢渣的效率提高(从80%提高到近100%)。本研究结果表明,在人工湿地或滤床中使用电弧炉钢渣是通过吸附和沉淀机制去除磷的一种有前景的解决方案。