Klimek Markus, Ubben Johannes F H, Ammann Jan, Borner Ulf, Klein Jan, Verbrugge Serge J C
Department of Anesthesiology, Erasmus University Medical Centre Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
J Neurosurg. 2006 Mar;104(3):350-9. doi: 10.3171/jns.2006.104.3.350.
This is the first observational study to compare perioperative pain character and intensity in patients undergoing different types of elective neurosurgical procedures.
A structured questionnaire was used to inquire about pain intensity, character, and management during the perioperative course, and the anticipated visual analogue scale (VAS) score in 649 patients during a 1-year period. The anticipated maximal postoperative VAS score was lower than the actual postoperative maximal VAS score and was independent of operation type and preoperative VAS score. Patients undergoing craniotomy experienced less pain than those undergoing spinal surgery. A majority of patients did not receive analgesic medication after surgery. Patients undergoing spinal surgery experienced higher preoperative VAS scores than those undergoing other neurosurgical treatments, with a shift from preoperative referred pain to postoperative local pain. After lumbar flavectomy, referred pain was greater than local pain. Patients with preoperative pain suffered significantly more postoperative pain than those without preoperative pain. In patients with postoperative surgery-related complications, VAS scores were higher than in those without complications.
Neurosurgical procedures cause more pain than anticipated. Anticipated pain intensity is independent of the operation type and preoperative pain intensity. Postcraniotomy on-demand analgesic medication is appropriate, if the nurses on the ward react quickly. Otherwise, patient-controlled analgesia might be an option. Other neurosurgical procedures require scheduled analgesic therapies. Spinal surgery requires intensive preoperative pain treatment; a shift in pain character from preoperative referred pain to postoperative local pain is expected. Patients with referred pain after lumbar flavectomy are prone to the most intense pain. Patients with preoperative pain experience more postoperative pain than those without preoperative pain and require more intensive pain management. Increased postoperative VAS scores are associated with surgery-related complications.
这是第一项比较接受不同类型择期神经外科手术患者围手术期疼痛特征和强度的观察性研究。
采用结构化问卷询问649例患者在1年期间围手术期的疼痛强度、特征及处理情况,以及预期视觉模拟量表(VAS)评分。预期术后最大VAS评分低于实际术后最大VAS评分,且与手术类型和术前VAS评分无关。接受开颅手术的患者比接受脊柱手术的患者疼痛轻。大多数患者术后未接受镇痛药物治疗。接受脊柱手术的患者术前VAS评分高于接受其他神经外科治疗的患者,疼痛特征从术前的牵涉痛转变为术后的局部痛。腰椎板切除术后,牵涉痛大于局部痛。术前有疼痛的患者术后疼痛明显多于无术前疼痛的患者。有术后手术相关并发症的患者VAS评分高于无并发症的患者。
神经外科手术引起的疼痛比预期更严重。预期疼痛强度与手术类型和术前疼痛强度无关。如果病房护士反应迅速,开颅手术后按需镇痛药物治疗是合适的。否则,患者自控镇痛可能是一种选择。其他神经外科手术需要定时镇痛治疗。脊柱手术需要强化术前疼痛治疗;预期疼痛特征会从术前牵涉痛转变为术后局部痛。腰椎板切除术后有牵涉痛的患者疼痛最剧烈。术前有疼痛的患者术后疼痛比无术前疼痛的患者更多,需要更强化的疼痛管理。术后VAS评分升高与手术相关并发症有关。