Baussano I, Bugiani M, Gregori D, van Hest R, Borraccino A, Raso R, Merletti F
Cancer Epidemiology Unit, S. Giovanni Battista Hospital and University of Turin, Centro di Prevenzione Oncologica (CPO) Piemonte, CeRMS, Turin, Italy.
Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2006 Apr;10(4):415-21.
Under-ascertainment and under-reporting of tuberculosis (TB) hampers surveillance and control. Case detection is improved by record linkage of case registers and under-reporting can be estimated by capture-recapture (CR) analysis.
To assess the completeness of the TB registration systems and estimation of TB incidence and under-reporting in the Piedmont Region of Italy in 2001.
Record linkage of the 'physician notification system', the TB laboratory register and the hospital records register, and subsequent three-sample CR analysis.
Record linkage identified 657 TB cases; CR analysis estimated 47 (95%CI 31-71) unrecorded cases. Under-reporting of the 'physician notification system' was estimated at 21% (95%CI 20-23). The overall estimated TB incidence rate was 16.7 cases per 100000 population (95%CI 16.3-17.3), varying according to the subset investigated: 12.7 for individuals from low TB prevalence countries and 214.1 for immigrants from high TB prevalence countries; 13.1 and 25.8 for persons aged < and > or = 60 years, respectively; and 32.1 in Turin, the regional capital and 10.8 in the rest of the region.
When multiple recording systems are available, record linkage and CR analysis can be used to assess TB incidence and the completeness of different registers, contributing to a more accurate surveillance of local TB epidemiology.
结核病的漏报和报告不足妨碍了监测与控制工作。通过病例登记册的记录关联可改善病例发现情况,而报告不足可通过捕获-再捕获(CR)分析进行估算。
评估2001年意大利皮埃蒙特大区结核病登记系统的完整性以及结核病发病率和报告不足情况。
对“医生报告系统”、结核病实验室登记册和医院记录登记册进行记录关联,随后进行三样本CR分析。
记录关联识别出657例结核病病例;CR分析估计有47例(95%可信区间31 - 71)未记录病例。“医生报告系统”的报告不足估计为21%(95%可信区间20 - 23)。总体估计结核病发病率为每10万人口16.7例(95%可信区间16.3 - 17.3),根据所调查的亚组有所不同:来自结核病低流行国家的个体为12.7例,来自结核病高流行国家的移民为214.1例;年龄<60岁和≥60岁的人群分别为13.1例和25.8例;在大区首府都灵为32.1例,在该大区其他地区为10.8例。
当有多个记录系统可用时,记录关联和CR分析可用于评估结核病发病率以及不同登记册的完整性,有助于更准确地监测当地结核病流行病学情况。