Silva Leonardo Victor España Rueda, Mello João Ferreira de, Mion Olavo
Division of Clinical Otorhinolaryngology, Hospital das Clínicas, Medical School, University of Sao Paulo.
Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2005 Sep-Oct;71(5):590-7. doi: 10.1016/s1808-8694(15)31262-3. Epub 2006 Mar 31.
Nowadays, the World Wide Web (Internet) is an information source for non-experts and physicians.
To evaluate, based on ethical principles, Brazilian web sites information about "allergic rhinitis". Allergic rhinitis is a very common disease, effecting more than 10% of the general population, leading to decrease in quality of life.
Review.
We performed the evaluation of 173 Brazilian web sites, which were obtained from four search engines (Google, Yahoo, AltaVista and Radar Uol). The web sites were evaluated according to the Manual of Ethical Principles, Regional Council of Medicine of the state of Sao Paulo (CREMESP), regarding transparency, honesty, quality, privacy, medical ethics, informed consent, responsibility and origin.
Among the analyzed web sites, 149 (86.1%) were not in accordance with the Manual of Ethical Principles of Regional Council of Medicine of the state of Sao Paulo (CREMESP). According to the analyzed items, the irregularities that were found were quality (84.4%), privacy (46.2%), honesty (18.5%), informed consent (15.6%), responsibility and origin (13.9%), transparency (12.1%), medical ethics (2.3%). There was inaccurate information in 24.3% of the analyzed sites.
The majority of the websites regarding allergic rhinitis are not in accordance with the ethical principles of CREMESP. In general, the quality of a great part of the Brazilian web sites that address "allergic rhinitis", and the quality of the information disseminated by them, are insufficient to satisfy doctors and patients.
如今,万维网(互联网)是普通人和医生获取信息的来源。
基于伦理原则,评估巴西网站上有关“变应性鼻炎”的信息。变应性鼻炎是一种非常常见的疾病,影响超过10%的普通人群,导致生活质量下降。
综述。
我们对173个巴西网站进行了评估,这些网站是从四个搜索引擎(谷歌、雅虎、阿尔塔维斯塔和雷达环球在线)获取的。根据圣保罗州医学区域委员会(CREMESP)的伦理原则手册,对这些网站在透明度、诚实性、质量、隐私、医学伦理、知情同意、责任和来源等方面进行了评估。
在分析的网站中,149个(86.1%)不符合圣保罗州医学区域委员会(CREMESP)的伦理原则手册。根据分析项目,发现的违规情况有质量(84.4%)、隐私(46.2%)、诚实性(18.5%)、知情同意(15.6%)、责任和来源(13.9%)、透明度(12.1%)、医学伦理(2.3%)。在24.3%的分析网站中存在不准确信息。
大多数关于变应性鼻炎的网站不符合CREMESP的伦理原则。总体而言,巴西大部分涉及“变应性鼻炎”的网站质量以及它们所传播的信息质量,不足以满足医生和患者的需求。