Samadbeik Mahnaz, Ahmadi Maryam, Mohammadi Ali, Mohseni Saravi Beniamin
Department of Health Information Technology, Lorestan University of Medical Sciences, Khorramabad, IR Iran.
Department of Health Information Management, School of Health Management and Information Science, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, IR Iran.
Iran Red Crescent Med J. 2014 Apr;16(4):e12866. doi: 10.5812/ircmj.12866. Epub 2014 Apr 5.
The Internet has provided great opportunities for disseminating both accurate and inaccurate health information. Therefore, the quality of information is considered as a widespread concern affecting the human life. Despite the increasingly substantial growth in the number of users, Persian health websites and the proportion of internet-using patients, little is known about the quality of Persian medical and health websites.
The current study aimed to first assess the quality, popularity and importance of websites providing Persian health-related information, and second to evaluate the correlation of the popularity and importance ranking with quality score on the Internet.
The sample websites were identified by entering the health-related keywords into four most popular search engines of Iranian users based on the Alexa ranking at the time of study. Each selected website was assessed using three qualified tools including the Bomba and Land Index, Google PageRank and the Alexa ranking.
The evaluated sites characteristics (ownership structure, database, scope and objective) really did not have an effect on the Alexa traffic global rank, Alexa traffic rank in Iran, Google PageRank and Bomba total score. Most websites (78.9 percent, n = 56) were in the moderate category (8 ≤ x ≤ 11.99) based on their quality levels. There was no statistically significant association between Google PageRank with Bomba index variables and Alexa traffic global rank (P > 0.05).
The Persian health websites had better Bomba quality scores in availability and usability guidelines as compared to other guidelines. The Google PageRank did not properly reflect the real quality of evaluated websites and Internet users seeking online health information should not merely rely on it for any kind of prejudgment regarding Persian health websites. However, they can use Iran Alexa rank as a primary filtering tool of these websites. Therefore, designing search engines dedicated to explore accredited Persian health-related Web sites can be an effective method to access high-quality Persian health websites.
互联网为传播准确和不准确的健康信息都提供了巨大机遇。因此,信息质量被视为影响人类生活的一个广泛关注的问题。尽管使用波斯语的健康网站数量以及使用互联网的患者比例都在日益显著增长,但对于波斯语医学和健康网站的质量却知之甚少。
本研究旨在首先评估提供波斯语健康相关信息的网站的质量、受欢迎程度和重要性,其次评估在互联网上受欢迎程度和重要性排名与质量得分之间的相关性。
通过在研究时基于Alexa排名向伊朗用户最常用的四个搜索引擎中输入与健康相关的关键词来确定样本网站。每个选定的网站使用三种合格工具进行评估,包括邦巴和兰德指数、谷歌网页排名和Alexa排名。
所评估网站的特征(所有权结构、数据库、范围和目标)对Alexa全球流量排名、伊朗的Alexa流量排名、谷歌网页排名和邦巴总分确实没有影响。根据质量水平,大多数网站(78.9%,n = 56)属于中等类别(8 ≤ x ≤ 11.99)。谷歌网页排名与邦巴指数变量和Alexa全球流量排名之间没有统计学上的显著关联(P > 0.05)。
与其他指南相比,波斯语健康网站在可用性和易用性指南方面具有更好的邦巴质量得分。谷歌网页排名不能恰当地反映所评估网站的实际质量,寻求在线健康信息的互联网用户不应仅仅依赖它对波斯语健康网站进行任何形式的预先判断。然而,他们可以将伊朗Alexa排名用作这些网站的主要筛选工具。因此,设计专门用于探索经认可的波斯语健康相关网站的搜索引擎可能是访问高质量波斯语健康网站的有效方法。