Sittel C, Buckel T, Baumann I, Plinkert P K
Klinik für Hals-Nasen-Ohrenheilkunde, Universität, Im Neuenheimer Feld 400, 69120, Heidelberg.
HNO. 2006 Dec;54(12):929-36. doi: 10.1007/s00106-006-1398-3.
Stenoses of the larynx and upper trachea in the pediatric population require a multidisciplinary approach and center-based treatment. Patterns of care and treatment strategies in Germany were evaluated using a standardized questionnaire.
A questionnaire was transmitted by telefax to 141 departments of Otorhinolaryngology (ORL) and to 214 pediatric (PED) departments. Using primarily multiple-choice questions variables regarding caseload, surgical techniques, cooperating institutions, criteria for surgical indications and subjective assessment of success rates were investigated.
The response rate was 55% (ORL) and 46% (PED), respectively, 34% of the replying ORL departments were offering tracheal surgery in children, with most of them using advanced surgical techniques. In 12 ORL departments 1-3 cases per year were operated, in 6 ORL departments more than 6 cases per year and 3 ORL departments were perceived as specialized centers for pediatric airway surgery by their peers. However, 41% of the PED departments were unable to identify a center for pediatric airway surgery.
In Germany, surgery for pediatric airway stenoses is not primarily focused on treatment centers. There is a significant information gap among German pediatricians regarding success rates of reconstructive airway surgery and available centers offering surgical therapy for this population. Several factors offer potential to be optimized in the care for children with a compromised airway and improving communication between otolaryngologists and pediatricians should be a primary goal in the future.
小儿喉和上气管狭窄需要多学科方法和以中心为基础的治疗。使用标准化问卷对德国的护理模式和治疗策略进行了评估。
通过传真向141个耳鼻咽喉科(ORL)科室和214个儿科(PED)科室发送了问卷。主要使用多项选择题对病例数量、手术技术、合作机构、手术适应症标准以及成功率的主观评估等变量进行了调查。
回复率分别为55%(ORL)和46%(PED),34%的回复ORL科室为儿童提供气管手术,其中大多数采用先进的手术技术。12个ORL科室每年进行1 - 3例手术,6个ORL科室每年进行超过6例手术,3个ORL科室被同行视为小儿气道手术的专业中心。然而,41%的PED科室无法确定小儿气道手术中心。
在德国,小儿气道狭窄手术并非主要集中在治疗中心。德国儿科医生在重建气道手术成功率以及为该人群提供手术治疗的可用中心方面存在显著的信息差距。在气道受损儿童的护理方面有几个因素有优化的潜力,未来改善耳鼻咽喉科医生和儿科医生之间的沟通应是首要目标。