Allen Roger J
Department of Physical Therapy, University of Puget Sound, 1500 North Warner, CMB 1070, Tacoma, WA 98416, USA.
Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am. 2006 May;17(2):315-45. doi: 10.1016/j.pmr.2005.12.007.
Evidence supporting the use of specific physical agents in the management of chronic pain conditions is not definitive; it is largely incomplete and sometimes contradictory. However, the use of agents in chronic pain management programs is common. Within the broad use of physical agents, they are rarely the sole modality of treatment. A 1995 American Physical Therapy Association position statement asserts that "Without documentation which justifies the necessity of the exclusive use of physical agents/modalities, the use of physical agents/modalities, in the absence of other skilled therapeutic or educational intervention, should not be considered physical therapy". Physical agents may serve as useful adjunctive modalities of pain relief or to enhance the effectiveness of other elements in therapy geared toward resolution of movement impairments and restoration of physical function. Given that a conclusive aggregate of findings is unlikely to exist for all permutations of patient conditions, combined with interacting therapeutic modalities, an evidence-based approach to pain management is not always possible or beneficial to the patient. In the face of inconclusive evidence, a theory-based approach may help determine if the therapeutic effect ofa given physical agent has the possibility of being a useful clinical tool in the context of treating a particular patient's mechanism of pain generation. Until controlled efficacy findings are definitive, careful individual patient response monitoring of thoughtful theoretical application of adjunctive physical agents may be a prudent approach to the management of chronic pain.
支持在慢性疼痛病症管理中使用特定物理因子的证据并不确凿;这些证据大多不完整,有时甚至相互矛盾。然而,在慢性疼痛管理项目中使用物理因子却很常见。在广泛使用物理因子的情况下,它们很少是唯一的治疗方式。美国物理治疗协会1995年的一份立场声明称:“如果没有文件证明有必要单独使用物理因子/治疗方式,那么在没有其他专业治疗或教育干预的情况下使用物理因子/治疗方式,不应被视为物理治疗”。物理因子可作为缓解疼痛的有用辅助方式,或提高旨在解决运动障碍和恢复身体功能的治疗中其他要素的有效性。鉴于不太可能针对患者病情的所有排列组合以及相互作用的治疗方式得出确凿的综合研究结果,基于证据的疼痛管理方法并不总是可行或对患者有益。面对不确定的证据,基于理论的方法可能有助于确定在治疗特定患者的疼痛产生机制时,某种给定物理因子的治疗效果是否有可能成为一种有用的临床工具。在对照疗效研究结果确定之前,对辅助物理因子的合理理论应用进行仔细的个体患者反应监测,可能是管理慢性疼痛的一种审慎方法。