Engelke Christoph, Rummeny Ernst J, Marten Katharina
Department of Radiology, Klinikum rechts der Isar, Technical University Munich, Ismaningerstrasse 22, Munich 81675, Germany.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2006 May;186(5):1265-71. doi: 10.2214/AJR.05.0650.
To predict cor pulmonale and short-term outcome in patients with pulmonary embolism (PE), we retrospectively investigated three morphology-based MDCT systems for scoring pulmonary artery obstruction.
Eighty-nine consecutive patients (51 men and 38 women; age range, 23-83 years; median, 63.3 years) with an MDCT diagnosis of acute PE were included in the study. Sixty-four patients had a coexisting malignancy. PE severity was assessed by two masked observers using three percentage arterial obstruction indexes: two severity scores adapted from conventional angiography (excluding and including arterial branch obstruction grading: scores A and B, respectively) and a CT-derived severity score (index C). Echocardiographic reports were reviewed for elevation of right ventricular pressure. Obstruction index results were analyzed for correlation with pulmonary artery pressures and for prediction of cor pulmonale and 30-day survival. Statistical analysis included kappa, analysis of variance, linear correlation, chi-square, and logistic regression tests.
Kappa values of 0.89, 0.82, and 0.78 were obtained for interobserver agreement on PE severity for indexes A, B, and C, respectively. PE severity was moderate but varied significantly between the scores (for index A: median, 25.0%; range, 6.3-100; for index B: median, 12.5%; range, 3.1-65.6; for index C: median, 7.1%; range, 0.65-65.8; p < 0.0001 [analysis of variance]). Index C correlated best with pulmonary artery pressures (r = 0.69; p < 0.0016) and the presence of cor pulmonale (p = 0.0051; odds ratio [OR], 1.20/percentage increase [95% confidence interval, 1.05-1.35]; for an index C cutoff of 21.3%: p = 0.0001; positive predictive value, 1; negative predictive value, 0.87). Eight patients died within 30 days after CT. The PE severity of indexes A and B was not associated with patient outcome (p > 0.05). With score C, PE severity was a significant predictor of early death (p = 0.018; OR, 1.03/percentage increase [95% confidence interval, 1.00-1.06]; for an index C cutoff of 21.3%: p = 0.018; overall OR, 6.77; positive predictive value, 0.24; negative predictive value, 0.96).
Mastora score was a significant predictor of cor pulmonale and short-term outcome and may therefore allow therapy and risk stratification in patients with acute PE.
为预测肺栓塞(PE)患者的肺心病及短期预后,我们回顾性研究了三种基于形态学的MDCT系统对肺动脉阻塞进行评分。
本研究纳入了89例经MDCT诊断为急性PE的连续患者(51例男性和38例女性;年龄范围23 - 83岁;中位数63.3岁)。64例患者合并有恶性肿瘤。由两名经验丰富的观察者使用三种动脉阻塞百分比指数评估PE严重程度:两种从传统血管造影改编而来的严重程度评分(分别排除和包括动脉分支阻塞分级:评分A和B)以及一个CT衍生的严重程度评分(指数C)。回顾超声心动图报告以评估右心室压力升高情况。分析阻塞指数结果与肺动脉压力的相关性以及对肺心病和30天生存率的预测。统计分析包括kappa检验、方差分析、线性相关、卡方检验和逻辑回归检验。
观察者间对PE严重程度的一致性,指数A、B和C的kappa值分别为0.89、0.82和0.78。PE严重程度为中度,但各评分之间差异显著(指数A:中位数25.0%;范围6.3 - 100;指数B:中位数12.5%;范围3.1 - 65.6;指数C:中位数7.1%;范围0.65 - 65.8;p < 0.0001[方差分析])。指数C与肺动脉压力相关性最佳(r = 0.69;p < 0.0016)以及与肺心病的存在相关性最佳(p = 0.0051;优势比[OR],1.20/百分比增加[95%置信区间,1.05 - 1.35];对于指数C截断值为21.3%:p = 0.0001;阳性预测值,1;阴性预测值,0.87)。8例患者在CT检查后30天内死亡。指数A和B的PE严重程度与患者预后无关(p > 0.05)。对于评分C,PE严重程度是早期死亡的显著预测因素(p = 0.018;OR,1.03/百分比增加[95%置信区间,1.00 - 1.06];对于指数C截断值为21.3%:p = 0.018;总体OR,6.77;阳性预测值,0.24;阴性预测值,0.96)。
马托拉评分是肺心病和短期预后的显著预测因素,因此可能有助于急性PE患者的治疗和风险分层。