Pavlotsky F, Barzilai A, Kasem R, Shpiro D, Trau H
Phototherapy Unit, Department of Dermatology, Sheba Medical Center, Tel Hashomer, Israel.
J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2006 May;20(5):565-72. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-3083.2006.01557.x.
Several options for treatment of early mycosis fungoides (MF) offer similar success rates. Previous small studies have shown UVB to be at least as effective as PUVA.
To summarize our experience with UVB treatment of early MF.
A retrospective analysis of early-stage MF patients treated by narrow band (NB) or broad band (BB) UVB in our institution between 1996 and 2002. Most patients achieving complete response (CR) were put on maintenance until natural sun exposure was possible and followed up every 3-6 months. The results were compared to those previously reported regarding PUVA.
Sixty-eight and 43 patients were treated by NB and BB UVB, respectively. Eighty-six per cent (84 and 89% in NB and BB UVB groups, respectively) of IA and 71% (78 and 44% in NB and BB UVB groups, respectively) of IB patients achieved CR within a mean of 12.8 and 10.6 weeks, respectively. When maintenance was stopped, 65 and 30% had not relapsed after an average follow up of 27 and 222 weeks, respectively. Non-relapse rate was 33 and 48% for those having had vs. those not having had maintenance, respectively.
Our results are comparable to all previously reported for skin-targeted treatments, including PUVA and, to our belief, reflect the nature of early MF, in which CR can probably be achieved in most of the patients. Among the responding patients there is no relapse during prolonged follow-up in about one third of the cases. Thus, we believe treatment should be stopped completely following first CR induction and maintenance treatment should be considered for relapsing patients only. Both broad and narrow UVB options are good and future choices should be made on the basis of short- and long-term side-effects.
早期蕈样肉芽肿(MF)的几种治疗方案成功率相似。先前的小型研究表明,UVB至少与PUVA一样有效。
总结我们用UVB治疗早期MF的经验。
对1996年至2002年在我们机构接受窄谱(NB)或宽谱(BB)UVB治疗的早期MF患者进行回顾性分析。大多数达到完全缓解(CR)的患者持续维持治疗,直到可以自然日晒,并每3 - 6个月随访一次。将结果与先前报道的PUVA治疗结果进行比较。
分别有68例和43例患者接受了NB UVB和BB UVB治疗。IA期患者中,分别有86%(NB UVB组和BB UVB组分别为84%和89%)和IB期患者中71%(NB UVB组和BB UVB组分别为78%和44%)在平均12.8周和10.6周内达到CR。停止维持治疗后,平均随访27周和222周时,分别有65%和30%未复发。接受维持治疗与未接受维持治疗的患者无复发率分别为33%和48%。
我们的结果与先前报道的所有皮肤靶向治疗(包括PUVA)的结果相当,并且我们认为,这反映了早期MF的性质,即大多数患者可能实现CR。在有反应的患者中,约三分之一在长期随访中无复发。因此,我们认为在首次诱导CR后应完全停止治疗,并仅对复发患者考虑维持治疗。宽谱和窄谱UVB方案都很好,未来应根据短期和长期副作用做出选择。