Papakostidis Costas, Grotz Martin R W, Papadokostakis George, Dimitriou Rozalia, Giannoudis Peter V
Department of Trauma & Orthopaedics, St James's University Hospital, Beckett Street, Leeds LS9 7TF, UK.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2006 Sep;450:193-202. doi: 10.1097/01.blo.0000218760.19934.2b.
New techniques of fracture fixation such as indirect reduction, careful soft tissue handling, and elastic fixation are being used in place of older methods of mechanical stabilization. These new techniques led to the concept of biologic plate fixation. We systematically reviewed the literature and provide an overall evaluation of femoral biologic fixation for fracture treatment. We analyzed 19 studies with 687 patients with 697 femoral fractures. Twenty-three percent of the fractures were subtrochanteric, 29% were diaphyseal, and 48% were supracondylar. Twenty-two percent were open fractures. The majority (81%) were comminuted and AO Types B and C. The overall union rate was 98.4%, with a mean time to union ranging from 10.7 to 24 weeks. Primary or secondary bone-grafting procedures were reported in all but one study with a frequency ranging from 0-55%. The most frequently recorded complications were malunion (0-29%) and reoperation (0-23%). The high union rate, low infection rate (2%), and occasional need for bone graft indicate biologic plate fixation is a viable alternative to modern nailing techniques, particularly in patients with polytrauma.
Therapeutic study, Level III.
诸如间接复位、谨慎处理软组织和弹性固定等骨折固定新技术正在取代旧的机械稳定方法。这些新技术催生了生物接骨板固定的概念。我们系统地回顾了文献,并对股骨骨折治疗的生物固定进行了全面评估。我们分析了19项研究,涉及687例患者的697例股骨干骨折。23%的骨折为转子下骨折,29%为骨干骨折,48%为髁上骨折。22%为开放性骨折。大多数(81%)为粉碎性骨折,AO分型为B型和C型。总体愈合率为98.4%,平均愈合时间为10.7至24周。除一项研究外,所有研究均报告了一期或二期植骨手术,频率为0 - 55%。最常记录的并发症是畸形愈合(0 - 29%)和再次手术(0 - 23%)。高愈合率、低感染率(2%)以及偶尔需要植骨表明生物接骨板固定是现代髓内钉技术的可行替代方法,特别是在多发伤患者中。
治疗性研究,III级。