David Henry P
Transnational Family Research Institute, Bethesda, MD, USA.
Reprod Health Matters. 2006 May;14(27):181-90. doi: 10.1016/S0968-8080(06)27219-7.
A long-held belief among mental health practitioners is that being born unwanted carries a risk of negative psychosocial development and poor mental health in adulthood. The Prague Study was designed to test this hypothesis. It followed the development and mental well-being of 220 children (now adults) born in 1961-63 in Prague to women twice denied abortion for the same unwanted pregnancy. The children were individually pair-matched at about age nine with 220 children born from accepted pregnancies when no abortion had been requested. This article brings together in one place the theoretical assumptions and hypotheses, the criteria for selecting the study participants and major findings from five follow-up waves conducted among the children around the ages of 9, 14-16, 21-23, 28-31 and 32-35 years, plus a sub-study of married unwanted pregnancy subjects and accepted pregnancy controls at ages 26-28. To control for potential confounding factors in data interpretation, all siblings of all subjects were included in the last two waves. It was found that differences in psychosocial development widened over time but lessened at around age 30. All the differences consistently disfavoured the unwanted pregnancy subjects, especially only children (no siblings). They became psychiatric patients (especially in-patients) more frequently than the accepted pregnancy controls and also more often than their siblings. The overall findings suggest that, in the aggregate, denial of abortion for unwanted pregnancy entails an increased risk for negative psychosocial development and mental well-being in adulthood.
心理健康从业者长期以来一直认为,出生时不被期待会带来负面心理社会发展风险以及成年后心理健康状况不佳。布拉格研究旨在验证这一假设。该研究追踪了1961年至1963年在布拉格出生的220名儿童(现已成年)的成长和心理健康状况,这些儿童的母亲因同一意外怀孕两次被拒绝堕胎。这些儿童在9岁左右时与220名因被接受的怀孕而出生的儿童进行了个体配对,这些被接受怀孕的儿童未提出堕胎请求。本文将理论假设、研究参与者的选择标准以及在这些儿童9岁、14 - 16岁、21 - 23岁、28 - 31岁和32 - 35岁左右进行的五次随访浪潮中的主要发现汇集在一起,此外还包括一项针对26 - 28岁已婚意外怀孕受试者和被接受怀孕对照组的子研究。为了在数据解读中控制潜在的混杂因素,所有受试者的兄弟姐妹都被纳入了最后两次随访。研究发现,心理社会发展方面的差异随着时间推移而扩大,但在30岁左右有所减小。所有差异始终对意外怀孕受试者不利,尤其是独生子女(无兄弟姐妹)。他们比被接受怀孕的对照组更频繁地成为精神科患者(尤其是住院患者),也比他们的兄弟姐妹更频繁。总体研究结果表明,总体而言,拒绝为意外怀孕堕胎会增加成年后负面心理社会发展和心理健康问题的风险。