Mangunkusumo Rt, Brug J, Duisterhout Js, de Koning Hj, Raat H
Department of Public Health, Erasmus MC-University Medical Center, Rotterdam, PO Box 2040, 3000 CA Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Health Educ Res. 2007 Feb;22(1):1-13. doi: 10.1093/her/cyl010. Epub 2006 May 19.
An Internet tool for monitoring, personalized feedback and referral was developed to support routine adolescent preventive care and was compared with usual practice using paper and pencil (P&P). A total of 1071 students (average age 15 years) from seven secondary schools were randomly assigned to the Internet or P&P group. The Internet group received a health and health-behavior assessment, tailored feedback on health and health behavior (specifically fruit consumption), and an online referral to see a physician/nurse if necessary. The P&P group received the same assessment, preprinted generic advice on fruit consumption and a mailed referral (where applicable). Students and physicians/nurses completed evaluation forms to assess indicators of feasibility, acceptability (i.e. satisfaction) and quality of each administration mode. Student participation rate was 87%. The electronic health feedback was positively evaluated. Students perceived the Internet-tailored fruit advice as more pleasant, more personally targeted and more enjoyable, but less credible than the generic preprinted advice (P < 0.01). No differences in indicators of acceptability and quality of consultation were found (P > or = 0.05). Thus, the Internet can be a valuable tool to support physicians/nurses in the field of preventive care. It is recommended to further optimize and evaluate the Internet as a tool.
开发了一种用于监测、个性化反馈和转诊的互联网工具,以支持青少年常规预防保健,并将其与使用纸笔(P&P)的常规做法进行比较。来自七所中学的1071名学生(平均年龄15岁)被随机分配到互联网组或纸笔组。互联网组接受了健康和健康行为评估、关于健康和健康行为(特别是水果消费)的定制反馈,以及必要时在线转诊去看医生/护士。纸笔组接受了相同的评估、预先印好的关于水果消费的一般建议以及邮寄转诊(如适用)。学生和医生/护士填写了评估表,以评估每种管理模式的可行性、可接受性(即满意度)和质量指标。学生参与率为87%。电子健康反馈得到了积极评价。学生认为互联网定制的水果建议更令人愉快、更具针对性、更有趣,但不如预先印好的一般建议可信(P < 0.01)。在可接受性和咨询质量指标方面未发现差异(P≥0.05)。因此,互联网可以成为支持医生/护士进行预防保健的有价值工具。建议进一步优化和评估互联网作为一种工具。