Hogarty G E, Anderson C M, Reiss D J, Kornblith S J, Greenwald D P, Ulrich R F, Carter M
Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, PA 15213.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1991 Apr;48(4):340-7. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1991.01810280056008.
We demonstrated earlier that a novel family psychoeducational approach and an individual social skills training approach designed for patients living in high-expressed emotion households each reduced schizophrenic relapse by one-half when compared with medication controls in the 1st year after hospital discharge. The combination of treatments resulted in no relapse. Results have now been obtained after 2 years of continuous treatment. By 24 months, a persistent and significant effect of family intervention on forestalling relapse was observed, but the effect of social skills training was lost late in the 2nd year. There was no additive effect on relapse that accrued to the combination of treatments. Beyond 2 years, however, the effect of family intervention was likely compromised as well. Treatment effects on the adjustment of survivors were circumscribed, due, in part, to study design characteristics. Effects generally favored the social skills-alone condition at 1 year and the family condition or combined family/social skills condition at 2 years.
我们之前证明,一种为生活在高情感表达家庭中的患者设计的新型家庭心理教育方法和个体社交技能训练方法,与出院后第一年的药物对照组相比,每种方法都将精神分裂症复发率降低了一半。两种治疗方法相结合未出现复发情况。现在已经获得了持续治疗两年后的结果。到24个月时,观察到家庭干预对预防复发有持续且显著的效果,但社交技能训练的效果在第二年后期消失。两种治疗方法相结合对复发没有累加效应。然而,超过两年后,家庭干预的效果可能也受到了影响。治疗对幸存者适应情况的影响有限,部分原因是研究设计的特点。一般来说,在1年时效果有利于单独进行社交技能训练的情况,在2年时有利于家庭干预情况或家庭/社交技能训练相结合的情况。