Williams Emily C, Kivlahan Daniel R, Saitz Richard, Merrill Joseph O, Achtmeyer Carol E, McCormick Kinsey A, Bradley Katharine A
Health Services Research & Development, VA Puget Sound Health Care System, Seattle, Wash 98101, USA.
Ann Fam Med. 2006 May-Jun;4(3):213-20. doi: 10.1370/afm.542.
Readiness to change drinking may influence the content or effectiveness of brief alcohol counseling. This study was designed to assess readiness to change and its relationship to alcohol misuse severity among primary care patients whose screening questionnaire was positive for alcohol misuse.
This study was a cross-sectional analysis of data collected from 2 consecutive mailed questionnaires. Male outpatients at 7 Veterans Affairs (VA) general medicine clinics were eligible if they returned both questionnaires, screened positive for alcohol misuse (augmented CAGE Questionnaire > or =1 point), responded to 3 readiness-to-change questions, and completed the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT). A validated algorithm based on 3 standardized questions categorized participants into 3 readiness groups (precontemplation, contemplation, action). Measures of alcohol misuse severity included AUDIT, CAGE, and the 3 consumption questions from the AUDIT (AUDIT-C). Analyses were descriptive; linear-by-linear associations between alcohol misuse severity and readiness were tested with chi2 statistics.
Response rates to the first and second surveys were 59% and 55%, respectively. Of the 6,419 eligible outpatients who screened positive for alcohol misuse, 4,797 (75%) reported any readiness to change (contemplation 24%, action 51%). Among patients with AUDIT scores >8, more than 90% indicated that they drank more than they should and/or had contemplated drinking less. Greater readiness was significantly associated with greater alcohol misuse severity (P <.001 for all measures).
Most primary care patients who screen positive for alcohol misuse indicate some readiness to change. Contrary to stereotypes of denial, those with greater alcohol misuse severity are more likely to report readiness to change.
改变饮酒行为的意愿可能会影响简短酒精咨询的内容或效果。本研究旨在评估初级保健患者中改变饮酒行为的意愿及其与酒精滥用严重程度的关系,这些患者的筛查问卷显示酒精滥用呈阳性。
本研究是对连续两份邮寄问卷收集的数据进行的横断面分析。7家退伍军人事务部(VA)综合内科诊所的男性门诊患者若同时返回两份问卷、酒精滥用筛查呈阳性(增强型CAGE问卷得分≥1分)、回答了3个关于改变意愿的问题并完成酒精使用障碍识别测试(AUDIT),则符合条件。基于3个标准化问题的有效算法将参与者分为3个改变意愿组(未考虑改变、考虑改变、行动)。酒精滥用严重程度的测量指标包括AUDIT、CAGE以及AUDIT中的3个饮酒量问题(AUDIT-C)。分析为描述性分析;使用卡方统计检验酒精滥用严重程度与改变意愿之间的线性关联。
第一次和第二次调查的回复率分别为59%和55%。在6419名酒精滥用筛查呈阳性的符合条件的门诊患者中,4797名(75%)表示有任何改变意愿(考虑改变24%,行动51%)。在AUDIT得分>8的患者中,超过90%表示饮酒量超过应有的量和/或曾考虑减少饮酒。更高的改变意愿与更高的酒精滥用严重程度显著相关(所有测量指标P<.001)。
大多数酒精滥用筛查呈阳性的初级保健患者表示有一定的改变意愿。与否认的刻板印象相反,酒精滥用严重程度较高的患者更有可能报告有改变意愿。