Elbl L, Vasova I, Kral Z, Tomaskova I, Smardova L, Wagnerova B, Jedlicka F, Vorlicek J
Dept. of Cardiology, Faculty Hospital Brno-Bohunice, Czech Republic.
J Chemother. 2006 Apr;18(2):199-208. doi: 10.1179/joc.2006.18.2.199.
The study was conducted to compare the presence of cardiotoxicity after the treatment of Hodgkin's disease with the standard ABVD or BEACOPP protocol. We examined 29 patients treated by means of the ABVD regimen and 34 treated with the BEACOPP regimen. Using rest echocardiography we assessed the left ventricular function before and after the therapy. One year after the completion of therapy, a control examination was performed with a battery of tests; the rest and dynamic stress echocardiography and cardiopulmonary tests were carried out to assess cardiopulmonary performance. A similar significant deterioration of ejection fraction and diastolic function was apparent after the treatment in both sub-groups with a further progression at the one-year control. Only one patient from the BEACOPP sub-group showed a pathological drop of EF <50%. The most affected parameters of left ventricular function (LV) were Doppler indices. We found a significant relationship of the parameters of LV function compared with age, the cumulative dose of doxorubicin and the cumulative dose of radiotherapy. Multivariate analysis demonstrated that diastolic dysfunction correlated with advanced age and the cumulative dose of doxorubicin, and decreased cardiopulmonary performance with advanced age, radiotherapy, and female gender. Both parameters were significantly influenced by the presence of hypertension. The used regimens demonstrated similar subclinical cardiotoxicity, thus the most aggressive regimen, BEACOPP, is not accompanied by a higher rate of cardiac impairment. The clinical value of such subclinical cardiotoxicity will be estimated in a further prospective follow-up.
本研究旨在比较采用标准ABVD或BEACOPP方案治疗霍奇金病后心脏毒性的发生情况。我们检查了29例采用ABVD方案治疗的患者和34例采用BEACOPP方案治疗的患者。通过静息超声心动图评估治疗前后的左心室功能。治疗结束一年后,进行一系列检查进行对照检查;进行静息和动态负荷超声心动图以及心肺测试以评估心肺功能。两个亚组治疗后射血分数和舒张功能均出现类似的显著恶化,在一年的对照检查中进一步进展。BEACOPP亚组中只有1例患者的EF病理性下降至<50%。左心室功能(LV)受影响最大的参数是多普勒指数。我们发现LV功能参数与年龄、阿霉素累积剂量和放疗累积剂量之间存在显著关系。多因素分析表明,舒张功能障碍与高龄和阿霉素累积剂量相关,心肺功能下降与高龄、放疗和女性性别相关。这两个参数均受到高血压存在的显著影响。所采用的方案显示出类似的亚临床心脏毒性,因此,最激进的方案BEACOPP,并未伴有更高的心脏损害发生率。这种亚临床心脏毒性的临床价值将在进一步的前瞻性随访中进行评估。