Chiarello Christine, Lombardino Linda J, Kacinik Natalie A, Otto Ronald, Leonard Christiana M
University of California, Riverside, USA.
Brain Lang. 2006 Aug;98(2):169-81. doi: 10.1016/j.bandl.2006.04.012. Epub 2006 Jun 5.
Individual differences in cortical anatomy are readily observable, but their functional significance for behaviors such as reading is not well understood. Here, we report a case of an apparent compensated dyslexic who had attained high achievement in visuospatial mathematics. Data from a detailed background interview, psychometric testing, divided visual field tasks measuring basic word recognition (word naming, nonword naming, and lexical decision), and more controlled word retrieval (verb, category, and rhyme generation), and measurements of his atypical brain structure are described. The findings suggested that enhanced "top-down" processing could provide the means to compensate for deficient "bottom-up" word decoding skills in this case. Relative to controls, this individual also evidenced unusually large asymmetries on several divided visual field lexical tasks, an extreme leftward asymmetry of the planum temporale, and a rare form of Sylvian fissure morphology (Steinmetz type 4, [Steinmetz, H., Ebeling, U., Huang, Y., & Kahn, T. (1990). Sulcus topography of the parietal opercular region: An anatomic and MR study. Brain and Language, 38, 515-533.]). We suggest that certain forms of brain organization may be associated with successful behavioral compensation for dyslexia, and that anatomical variations in the right hemisphere may be important contributors to individual differences in reading acquisition and achievement.
大脑皮层解剖结构的个体差异很容易观察到,但它们对诸如阅读等行为的功能意义却尚未得到很好的理解。在此,我们报告一例明显的代偿性阅读障碍患者,该患者在视觉空间数学方面取得了很高成就。本文描述了来自详细背景访谈、心理测量测试、测量基本单词识别的半视野任务(单词命名、非单词命名和词汇判断)、更具控制性的单词检索任务(动词、类别和押韵生成)的数据,以及对其非典型脑结构的测量结果。研究结果表明,增强的“自上而下”加工可能为在这种情况下补偿不足的“自下而上”单词解码技能提供途径。相对于对照组,该个体在几项半视野词汇任务中还表现出异常大的不对称性、颞平面的极端向左不对称,以及一种罕见的大脑外侧裂形态(施泰因梅茨4型,[施泰因梅茨,H.,埃贝林,U.,黄,Y.,& 卡恩,T.(1990年)。顶叶岛盖区的沟回地形:解剖学和磁共振研究。《大脑与语言》,38,515 - 533。])。我们认为,某些形式的大脑组织可能与阅读障碍的成功行为代偿有关,并且右半球的解剖变异可能是阅读习得和成就个体差异的重要因素。