Akhtar S, Carpenter T E, Rathi S K
Department of Community Medicine and Behavioural Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, Kuwait University, Safat, Kuwait.
Epidemiol Infect. 2007 Jan;135(1):27-33. doi: 10.1017/S0950268806006364. Epub 2006 Jun 2.
A simulation study using Greenwood's chain-binomial model was carried out to elucidate the spread and control of Mycobacterium tuberculosis among the household contacts of infectious pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) patients. Based on the observed data, the maximum-likelihood estimates (+/-S.E.) of chain-binomial probabilities of intra-household M. tuberculosis transmission from an index case in 3-person and 4-person households were 0.313+/-0.008 and 0.325+/-0.009 respectively. The chi2 goodness-of-fit test of observed and simulated mean expected frequencies of cases revealed good fit for 3-person (P=0.979) and 4-person (P=0.546) households. With the assumption of varying risk of M. tuberculosis transmission across the households under beta-distribution, goodness-of-fit tests of observed and mean simulated expected frequencies revealed the inadequacy of Greenwood's chain-binomial model both for 3-person (P=0.0185) and 4-person (P<0.001) households. Simulated M. tuberculosis control strategy comprising efficient diagnosis, segregation and prompt antibiotic therapy of index pulmonary TB patients showed a substantial reduction of new cases among the household contacts in both household sizes. In conclusion, segregation coupled with prompt antibiotic therapy of the index case, chemoprophylaxis of M. tuberculosis-exposed household contacts, and the assessment of household environmental risks to devise and implement an educational programme may help reduce the TB burden in this and similar settings.
利用格林伍德链二项式模型进行了一项模拟研究,以阐明传染性肺结核(TB)患者家庭接触者中结核分枝杆菌的传播与控制情况。基于观察数据,在3人户和4人户中,索引病例在家庭内传播结核分枝杆菌的链二项式概率的最大似然估计值(±标准误)分别为0.313±0.008和0.325±0.009。对观察到的和模拟的病例平均预期频数进行卡方拟合优度检验,结果显示该模型对3人户(P = 0.979)和4人户(P = 0.546)拟合良好。假设在β分布下家庭间结核分枝杆菌传播风险不同,对观察到的和模拟的平均预期频数进行拟合优度检验,结果显示格林伍德链二项式模型对3人户(P = 0.0185)和4人户(P < 0.001)均不适用。模拟的结核控制策略包括对索引肺结核患者进行有效诊断、隔离和及时抗生素治疗,结果显示在这两种家庭规模中,家庭接触者中的新发病例都大幅减少。总之,对索引病例进行隔离并及时给予抗生素治疗、对接触结核分枝杆菌的家庭接触者进行化学预防,以及评估家庭环境风险以制定和实施教育计划,可能有助于减轻本地区及类似环境中的结核病负担。