Cheung Benjamin K, Morze Conrad J, Jones Mark A, Venkatesh Bala
Department of Intensive Care, Princess Alexandra Hospital, Brisbane, QLD, Australia.
Crit Care Resusc. 2006 Jun;8(2):100-6.
Published data suggest that the quality of information on diseases accessible on the Internet using non-medical search engines is poor. Such data do not exist for illnesses requiring intensive care. This study investigated the accuracy of health information about head injury pertaining to intensive care on the Internet, and correlated website characteristics with the quality of their content.
A cross-sectional survey was conducted of the first 20 websites retrieved by the seven most frequently used search engines, with the information evaluated by two independent observers. Inter-observer reliability was evaluated using the kappa statistic. Website information on head injury was compared with "gold standard" guidelines from the Brain Trauma Foundation. Website characteristics were assessed, and their correlation with quality of website content was analysed.
58 websites were assessed. Weighted kappa for interobserver agreement on quality scores was 0.72. The median content score was 2 (interquartile range, 0-4) out of a possible maximum of 23. Logistic regression analysis suggested that medical authors, government sponsors, and being in the second 10 websites retrieved by a search engine were associated with higher website quality scores, while financial incentive and advertisement were associated with lower quality scores.
This study demonstrated that information retrieved by the public on head injury from non-medical websites may be incomplete and inaccurate. It also identified website characteristics associated with poor content quality.
已发表的数据表明,使用非医学搜索引擎在互联网上获取的疾病信息质量较差。但关于重症监护所需疾病的此类数据并不存在。本研究调查了互联网上有关重症监护的头部损伤健康信息的准确性,并将网站特征与其内容质量相关联。
对七个最常用的搜索引擎检索到的前20个网站进行横断面调查,由两名独立观察员对信息进行评估。使用kappa统计量评估观察者间的可靠性。将关于头部损伤的网站信息与脑创伤基金会的“金标准”指南进行比较。评估网站特征,并分析它们与网站内容质量的相关性。
共评估了58个网站。观察者间在质量评分上的一致性加权kappa为0.72。内容评分中位数为2(四分位间距,0 - 到4),满分可能为23分。逻辑回归分析表明,医学作者、政府赞助以及在搜索引擎检索到的第二个10个网站中与较高的网站质量评分相关,而经济激励和广告则与较低的质量评分相关。
本研究表明,公众从非医学网站检索到的关于头部损伤 的信息可能不完整且不准确。它还确定了与内容质量差相关的网站特征。