Mauad Raul J, Shimizu Maria H M, Mauad Thais, de Tolosa Erasmo M C
Department of Experimental Surgery, School of Medicine, Sao Paulo University, Av. Dr Arnaldo 455, 01246-903 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil.
J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2006;59(4):387-92. doi: 10.1016/j.bjps.2005.07.005.
Nicotine reduces skin-flap survival. Pharmacologic therapy may represent an alternative treatment strategy to counteract nicotine effects in the flap surgery setting. In this study, we have compared the isolated and associated actions of the vasoactive drugs buflomedil and pentoxifylline in the viability of dorsal cutaneous flaps of rats treated with subcutaneous doses of nicotine.
The survival of modified McFarlane skin flaps was assessed on post-operative day 7. Nicotine group received 4 mg/kg nicotine during 40 days pre-operatively and 7 days post-operatively. Nicotine+buflomedil group received nicotine and 6 mg/kg buflomedil 24 h pre-operatively and 7 days post-operatively. Nicotine+pentoxifylline group received nicotine and 20 mg/kg pentoxifylline in 15 pre-operatively and 7 post-operatively days. Nicotine+buflomedil+ pentoxifylline group received nicotine and both drugs administered as above. Control group received daily 1 ml normal saline during 40 days pre-operatively and 7 days post-operatively. Using image analysis, five different flap areas were quantified: Total, preserved, necrotic, ischaemic and viability. Viability areas comprised the sum of ischaemic and preserved areas.
Nicotine treated animals had lower percentage of viability areas (60.7% +/- 6.8) than the control group (73.7% +/- 9.5), p=0.016. The percentage of viability areas in the buflomedil (76.4% +/- 11.4), pentoxifylline (74.2% +/- 15.6) and buflomedil+ pentoxifylline (74.0% +/- 9.7) groups were larger than the nicotine group (p=0.002, p=0.011 and p=0.012, respectively). There were no significant differences in the viability areas when drugs were used isolated or in association. We further demonstrated that the increase in the viability area of the buflomedil and pentoxifylline groups (isolated or in association) was due to increase in ischaemic areas.
Both drugs equally increased flap survival in nicotine treated animals. Viability areas increased due to larger ischaemic areas, probably as a reflex of the action of these drugs in sites of partial circulatory deficit.
尼古丁会降低皮瓣存活率。药物治疗可能是在皮瓣手术中抵消尼古丁作用的一种替代治疗策略。在本研究中,我们比较了血管活性药物丁咯地尔和己酮可可碱在皮下注射尼古丁处理的大鼠背部皮瓣存活中的单独作用及联合作用。
在术后第7天评估改良麦克法兰皮瓣的存活情况。尼古丁组在术前40天及术后7天接受4mg/kg尼古丁。尼古丁+丁咯地尔组在术前24小时及术后7天接受尼古丁和6mg/kg丁咯地尔。尼古丁+己酮可可碱组在术前15天及术后7天接受尼古丁和20mg/kg己酮可可碱。尼古丁+丁咯地尔+己酮可可碱组接受尼古丁及上述两种药物。对照组在术前40天及术后7天每天接受1ml生理盐水。使用图像分析对五个不同的皮瓣区域进行量化:总面积、保留面积、坏死面积、缺血面积和存活面积。存活面积包括缺血面积和保留面积之和。
尼古丁处理的动物的存活面积百分比(60.7%±6.8)低于对照组(73.7%±9.5),p=0.016。丁咯地尔组(76.4%±11.4)、己酮可可碱组(74.2%±15.6)和丁咯地尔+己酮可可碱组(74.0%±9.7)的存活面积百分比均大于尼古丁组(分别为p=0.002、p=0.011和p=0.012)。单独使用或联合使用药物时,存活面积无显著差异。我们进一步证明,丁咯地尔组和己酮可可碱组(单独或联合使用)存活面积的增加是由于缺血面积增加。
两种药物均能同样地提高尼古丁处理动物的皮瓣存活率。存活面积增加是由于缺血面积增大,这可能是这些药物在部分循环不足部位作用的一种反应。