Evans Ceri
The Medlicott Academic Unit of Forensic Psychiatry, Forensic Psychiatry Services, Hillmorton Hospital, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2006 Jun-Jul;40(6-7):508-18. doi: 10.1080/j.1440-1614.2006.01833.x.
Little systematic evidence is available about how violent offenders remember and think about their violent crimes. The general aim of this article is to selectively review a range of different 'types' of memory disturbance and their risk factors, in an attempt to draw together different strands of research concerning memories of offending that might usefully be considered together for clinical purposes. A selective review of psychiatric or psychological studies related to amnesia, intrusive memories, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), ruminations, and pleasurable memories was performed. The body of research on amnesia in relation to violent crime is relatively small and is subject to significant limitations. The empirical base of studies identifying intrusive memories arising from violent crime is also very limited, with no previous published study primarily focusing on description of the form and content of intrusive memories related to acts of violence in a population of violent offenders. A small number of studies have investigated PTSD directly arising from the commission of a violent or sexual crime, in those with mental illness. No published studies that investigated the presence of ruminations related to violent offending were identified. No systematic comparative studies were identified that described the form and content that positive memories of non-sexual violence might take. Relevant phenomenological reports from extreme populations raise concerns about selection bias. A memory-based approach to eliciting descriptions of violent offending may elicit clinical information relevant to violence risk assessment and therapeutic interventions within forensic settings.
关于暴力罪犯如何回忆和思考他们的暴力犯罪行为,几乎没有系统的证据。本文的总体目标是有选择地回顾一系列不同“类型”的记忆障碍及其风险因素,试图整合有关犯罪记忆的不同研究线索,这些线索可能出于临床目的而被有益地综合考虑。对与失忆、侵入性记忆、创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)、反复思考和愉悦记忆相关的精神病学或心理学研究进行了有选择的回顾。关于暴力犯罪相关失忆的研究体量相对较小,且存在重大局限性。识别由暴力犯罪引发的侵入性记忆的研究的实证基础也非常有限,此前没有发表过的研究主要专注于描述暴力罪犯群体中与暴力行为相关的侵入性记忆的形式和内容。少数研究调查了患有精神疾病的人因实施暴力或性犯罪而直接产生的创伤后应激障碍。未发现有已发表的研究调查与暴力犯罪相关的反复思考的存在情况。未发现有系统的比较研究描述非性暴力的积极记忆可能呈现的形式和内容。来自极端群体的相关现象学报告引发了对选择偏差的担忧。一种基于记忆的方法来引出对暴力犯罪的描述,可能会引出与法医环境中的暴力风险评估和治疗干预相关的临床信息。