McGarvey Lorcan P A, Carton Carol, Gamble Lucy A, Heaney Liam G, Shepherd Richard, Ennis Madeline, MacMahon Joseph
Department of Respiratory Medicine, Belfast City Hospital, N. Ireland, UK.
Cough. 2006 Jun 16;2:4. doi: 10.1186/1745-9974-2-4.
Chronic cough may cause significant emotional distress and although patients are not routinely assessed for co-existent psychomorbidity, a cough that is refractory to any treatment is sometimes suspected to be functional in origin. It is not known if patients with chronic cough referred for specialist evaluation have emotional impairment but failure to recognise this may influence treatment outcomes. In this cross-sectional study, levels of psychomorbidity were measured in patients referred to a specialist cough clinic.
Fifty-seven patients (40 female), mean age 47.5 (14.3) years referred for specialist evaluation of chronic cough (mean cough duration 69.2 (78.5) months) completed the Hospital Anxiety and Depression (HAD) scale, State Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) and the Crown Crisp Experiential Index (CCEI) at initial clinic presentation. Subjects then underwent a comprehensive diagnostic evaluation, after which they were classified as either treated cough (TC) or idiopathic cough (IC). Questionnaire scores were compared between TC (n = 42) and IC (n = 15).
Using the HAD scale, 33% of all cough patients were identified as anxious, while 16% experienced depression. The STAI scores suggested moderate or high trait anxiety in 48% of all coughers. Trait anxiety was significantly higher among TC (p < 0.001) and IC patients (p = 0.004) compared to a healthy adult population. On the CCEI, mean scores on the phobic anxiety, somatisation, depression, and obsession subscales were significantly higher among all cough patients than the published mean scores for healthy controls. Only state anxiety was significantly higher in IC patients compared with TC patients (p < 0.05).
Patients with chronic cough appear to have increased levels of emotional upset although psychological questionnaires do not readily distinguish between idiopathic coughers and those successfully treated.
慢性咳嗽可能会导致严重的情绪困扰,尽管患者通常不会接受并存精神疾病的常规评估,但对任何治疗均无效的咳嗽有时被怀疑源于功能性因素。目前尚不清楚转诊至专科门诊进行评估的慢性咳嗽患者是否存在情绪障碍,但未能认识到这一点可能会影响治疗效果。在这项横断面研究中,对转诊至专科咳嗽门诊的患者的精神疾病水平进行了测量。
57例患者(40例女性),平均年龄47.5(14.3)岁,因慢性咳嗽转诊至专科门诊进行评估(平均咳嗽持续时间69.2(78.5)个月),在首次门诊就诊时完成医院焦虑抑郁量表(HAD)、状态特质焦虑量表(STAI)和克朗普斯体验指数(CCEI)。受试者随后接受了全面的诊断评估,之后被分为已治愈咳嗽组(TC)或特发性咳嗽组(IC)。比较了TC组(n = 42)和IC组(n = 15)的问卷得分。
使用HAD量表,所有咳嗽患者中有33%被确定为焦虑,16%有抑郁症状。STAI评分显示,所有咳嗽患者中有48%存在中度或高度特质焦虑。与健康成年人群相比,TC组(p < 0.001)和IC组患者(p = 0.004)的特质焦虑明显更高。在CCEI上,所有咳嗽患者在恐惧焦虑、躯体化、抑郁和强迫观念分量表上的平均得分明显高于健康对照人群公布的平均得分。与TC组患者相比,只有IC组患者的状态焦虑明显更高(p < 0.05)。
慢性咳嗽患者的情绪困扰水平似乎有所升高,尽管心理问卷难以区分特发性咳嗽患者和已成功治愈咳嗽的患者。