Ottewill Roger, Demain Sara, Ellis-Hill Caroline, Greenyer Corinne Hutt, Kileff Joanna
Centre for Learning and Teaching, University of Southampton, Highfield, UK.
Med Teach. 2006 Jun;28(4):e120-6. doi: 10.1080/01421590600726698.
With patient expertise being afforded greater legitimacy in healthcare provision, there is a strengthening case for involving patients more creatively in the education of healthcare professionals. This paper reports on the results of a small-scale educational research project designed to explore how third-year physiotherapy students experienced a teaching session on the subject of strokes, led by two expert patients, and what they learnt from it. Applying a qualitative methodology, six students were interviewed in depth about the experience. Four key pedagogic themes emerged from the analysis of the interview transcripts. The first related to the differences between the expert patients in terms of their backgrounds and their reactions to experiencing a stroke and of their respective contributions to the session. A second concerned the anxieties students felt in participating in a session of this kind, since there were various departures from the norm, and what they should take from it in terms of their learning. A third theme was uncertainty regarding the relationship between the presenters and students. The fourth theme was the impact on student learning given that it had not been a conventional session. Notwithstanding any misgivings the session helped to validate the contribution that those who have direct experience of a clinical condition can make to the education of healthcare professionals, particularly in the affective domain. In planning sessions of this kind it is recommended that presenters are chosen with a view to challenging stereotypes and that they are encouraged to tell their stories in an open and flexible manner, albeit within a framework of intended learning outcomes. Students need to approach the session with an open mind and, above all, tutors need to be prepared to take risks.
随着患者专业知识在医疗保健服务中获得更大的合法性,越来越有理由让患者更有创造性地参与医疗专业人员的教育。本文报告了一个小规模教育研究项目的结果,该项目旨在探索三年级物理治疗专业学生如何体验由两名专家患者主导的关于中风主题的教学课程,以及他们从中学到了什么。采用定性研究方法,对六名学生进行了关于该经历的深入访谈。对访谈记录的分析得出了四个关键的教学主题。第一个主题涉及专家患者在背景、中风经历反应以及他们在课程中的各自贡献方面的差异。第二个主题关注学生在参与此类课程时所感受到的焦虑,因为存在各种与常规不同之处,以及他们在学习方面应从中获得什么。第三个主题是关于授课者与学生之间关系的不确定性。第四个主题是鉴于这不是一次常规课程,对学生学习的影响。尽管存在任何疑虑,但该课程有助于证实那些有临床疾病直接经验的人对医疗专业人员教育,特别是在情感领域所做贡献的有效性。在规划此类课程时,建议选择能够挑战刻板印象的授课者,并鼓励他们以开放灵活的方式讲述自己的故事,尽管要在预期学习成果的框架内。学生需要以开放的心态参加课程,最重要的是,导师需要做好冒险的准备。