Dockrell Julie E, Lindsay Geoff, Letchford Becky, Mackie Clare
Psychology and Human Development, Institute of Education, University of London, UK.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2006 Jul-Aug;41(4):423-40. doi: 10.1080/13682820500442073.
Children with specific speech and language difficulties (SSLD) pose a challenge to the education system, and to speech and language therapists who support them, as a result of their language needs and associated educational and social-behavioural difficulties. The development of inclusion raises questions regarding appropriate provision, whether the tradition of language units or full inclusion into mainstream schools.
To gather the views of speech and language therapy service managers in England and Wales regarding approaches to service delivery, terminology and decision-making for educational provision, and the use of direct and indirect (consultancy) models of intervention.
The study reports on a national survey of speech and language therapy (SLT) services in England and Wales (129 respondents, 72.1% response rate) and interviews with 39 SLT service managers.
Provision varied by age group with support to children in the mainstream common from pre-school to the end of Key Stage 2 (up to 11 years), and to those in designated specialist provision, common at Key Stages 1/2 (ages 5-11 years), but less prevalent at Key Stages 3/4 (11-16 years). Decision-making regarding provision was influenced by the lack of common terminology, with SSLD and specific language impairment (SLI) the most common, and criteria, including the use of the discrepancy model for defining SSLD. Practice was influenced by the difficulties in distinguishing children with SSLD from those with autistic spectrum disorder, and difficulties translating policies into practice.
The implications of the study are discussed with reference to SLT practice, including consultancy models, and the increasingly prevalent policy in local education authorities of inclusion of children with special educational needs.
有特定言语和语言障碍(SSLD)的儿童给教育系统以及支持他们的言语和语言治疗师带来了挑战,这是由于他们的语言需求以及相关的教育和社会行为困难所致。融合教育的发展引发了关于适当服务提供方式的问题,无论是语言单元传统模式还是完全融入主流学校的模式。
收集英格兰和威尔士言语和语言治疗服务管理者对于服务提供方式、教育服务术语和决策制定,以及直接和间接(咨询)干预模式使用的看法。
该研究报告了对英格兰和威尔士言语和语言治疗(SLT)服务的全国性调查(129名受访者,72.1%的回复率)以及对39名SLT服务管理者的访谈。
服务提供因年龄组而异,从学前到关键阶段2结束(至11岁),主流学校中的儿童获得支持较为普遍;对于那些在指定特殊服务机构的儿童,在关键阶段1/2(5 - 11岁)较为常见,但在关键阶段3/4(11 - 16岁)则不太普遍。关于服务提供的决策受到缺乏通用术语的影响,其中SSLD和特定语言障碍(SLI)最为常见,还受到标准的影响,包括使用差异模型来定义SSLD。实践受到难以区分患有SSLD的儿童与患有自闭症谱系障碍的儿童,以及难以将政策转化为实践的影响。
该研究的影响将结合SLT实践进行讨论,包括咨询模式,以及地方教育当局中越来越普遍的将有特殊教育需求的儿童纳入主流教育的政策。