Williamson Dhelia M, White Mary C, Poole Charles, Kleinbaum David, Vogt Robert, North Kari
Division of Health Studies, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
Environ Health Perspect. 2006 Jul;114(7):1065-71. doi: 10.1289/ehp.8946.
Residents living in communities near Superfund sites have expressed concern that releases from these facilities affect their health, including adverse effects on their immune systems. We used data from six cross-sectional studies to evaluate whether people who live near several Superfund sites are more likely to have individual immunoglobulin test results (IgA, IgG, and IgM) below or above the reference range than those who live in comparison areas with no Superfund site. Study participants consisted of target-area residents who lived close to a Superfund site and comparison-area residents who were not located near any Superfund or hazardous waste sites. A consistent modeling strategy was used across studies to assess the magnitude of the relationship between area of residence and immunoglobulin test results, adjusting for potential confounders and effect modifiers. In all study areas, the results suggest that people who live near a Superfund site may have been more likely to have IgA test results above the reference range than comparison areas residents regardless of modeling strategy employed. The effect measures were larger for residents who lived in communities near military bases with groundwater contamination. For all analyses the wide confidence intervals reflect uncertainty in the magnitude of these effects. To adequately address the question of whether the immune system is affected by low-level exposures to hazardous substances, we recommend that more functional immunotoxicity tests be conducted in human populations where individual exposure information is available or when it can be reasonably estimated from environmental exposure measurements.
居住在超级基金污染场地附近社区的居民担心,这些设施的污染物排放会影响他们的健康,包括对其免疫系统产生不良影响。我们利用六项横断面研究的数据,评估居住在多个超级基金污染场地附近的人群,其个体免疫球蛋白检测结果(IgA、IgG和IgM)高于或低于参考范围的可能性,是否高于居住在无超级基金污染场地对照区域的人群。研究参与者包括居住在超级基金污染场地附近的目标区域居民,以及未居住在任何超级基金或危险废物场地附近的对照区域居民。各项研究采用了一致的建模策略,以评估居住区域与免疫球蛋白检测结果之间关系的强度,并对潜在的混杂因素和效应修饰因素进行了调整。在所有研究区域,结果表明,无论采用何种建模策略,居住在超级基金污染场地附近的人群,其IgA检测结果高于参考范围的可能性可能高于对照区域居民。对于居住在受地下水污染的军事基地附近社区的居民,效应量更大。在所有分析中,较宽的置信区间反映了这些效应强度的不确定性。为了充分解决免疫系统是否受到低水平有害物质暴露影响的问题,我们建议在能够获取个体暴露信息或可根据环境暴露测量合理估算暴露信息的人群中,开展更多功能性免疫毒性测试。