类风湿性关节炎患者颈椎融合术后下颈椎不稳的长期发生率。
Long-term incidence of subaxial cervical spine instability following cervical arthrodesis surgery in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.
作者信息
Clarke Michelle J, Cohen-Gadol Aaron A, Ebersold Michael J, Cabanela Miguel E
机构信息
Department of Neurologic Surgery, Mayo Clinic and Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN 55902, USA.
出版信息
Surg Neurol. 2006 Aug;66(2):136-40; discussion 140. doi: 10.1016/j.surneu.2005.12.037.
OBJECTIVE
Cervical spine deformities are well-known complications of RA. A 5- to 20-year follow-up of 51 consecutive rheumatoid patients who underwent posterior cervical arthrodesis is presented to evaluate the recurrence of instability and need for further surgery.
METHODS
We conducted a retrospective review of the clinical features of 11 men and 40 women with an established diagnosis of RA and associated cervical deformities who underwent cervical spine surgery at the Mayo Clinic (Rochester, MN) between 1979 and 1990. Their mean age was 61 +/- 10 years (SD), and their duration of RA averaged 21 +/- 8.9 years (SD). There were 22 patients who presented with myelopathy, 7 with radiculopathy, and 22 with instability/neck pain. There were 33 patients with AAS, 2 with SMO process into the foramen magnum, 8 with SAS, and 8 with combinations of these. Preoperative reduction was followed by decompression and fusion using wiring techniques and autologous bone graft. Postoperative halo orthosis was provided for at least 3 months. The mean follow-up was 8.3 +/- 6 years (SD).
RESULTS
There were 31 patients (61%) who underwent atlantoaxial arthrodesis, 17 patients (33%) who underwent subaxial, and 3 patients (6%) who underwent occipitocervical arthrodesis. During follow-up, 39% (13/33) of patients with AAS developed nonsymptomatic (6) or symptomatic/unstable (7) SASs subsequent to C1-C2 fusion. The latter 7 patients (21%) subsequently required extension of their arthrodesis. Adjacent segment disease was most common at the C3-C4 interspace after atlantoaxial fusion in 62% (8/13). Among the 8 patients who underwent isolated cervical fusion for SAS, 1 patient (1/8, 12%) developed adjacent instability after a fall and required extension of the previous fusion. No secondary procedure was required for the 6 patients initially stabilized by C1-(C6-T1) fusions for combinations of AAS + SAS. None of the patients initially treated by C1-C2 arthrodesis for AAS progressed to SMO.
CONCLUSIONS
The incidence of subaxial instability in patients with rheumatoid disease who underwent cervical arthrodesis may be higher than previously reported, indicating the need for continued follow-up in these patients. Adjacent segment disease may be most common at the C3-C4 level following atlantoaxial fusion. Early stabilization of the C1-C2 complex in the patients with AAS may potentially prevent progression of SMO.
目的
颈椎畸形是类风湿关节炎(RA)众所周知的并发症。本文对51例连续接受颈椎后路融合术的类风湿患者进行了5至20年的随访,以评估不稳定的复发情况及进一步手术的必要性。
方法
我们对1979年至1990年间在梅奥诊所(明尼苏达州罗切斯特)接受颈椎手术、确诊为RA并伴有颈椎畸形的11名男性和40名女性患者的临床特征进行了回顾性研究。他们的平均年龄为61±10岁(标准差),RA病程平均为21±8.9年(标准差)。有22例患者表现为脊髓病,7例为神经根病,22例为不稳定/颈部疼痛。有33例患者患有寰枢椎半脱位(AAS),2例为枕骨大孔区齿状突陷入(SMO),8例为下颈椎不稳综合征(SAS),8例为这些情况的组合。术前进行复位,然后采用钢丝技术和自体骨移植进行减压和融合。术后使用头环支具至少3个月。平均随访时间为8.3±6年(标准差)。
结果
31例患者(61%)接受了寰枢椎融合术,17例患者(33%)接受了下颈椎融合术,3例患者(6%)接受了枕颈融合术。在随访期间,33例AAS患者中有39%(13/33)在C1-C2融合术后出现无症状(6例)或有症状/不稳定(7例)的SAS。后7例患者(21%)随后需要延长融合范围。寰枢椎融合术后,相邻节段疾病最常见于C3-C4间隙,发生率为62%(8/13)。在8例因SAS单独接受颈椎融合术的患者中,1例患者(1/8,12%)在跌倒后出现相邻节段不稳定,需要延长先前的融合范围。6例因AAS+SAS组合最初通过C1-(C6-T1)融合获得稳定的患者无需二次手术。最初因AAS接受C1-C2融合术治疗的患者均未进展为SMO。
结论
接受颈椎融合术的类风湿疾病患者下颈椎不稳定的发生率可能高于先前报道,表明这些患者需要持续随访。寰枢椎融合术后,相邻节段疾病可能最常见于C3-C4水平。对AAS患者早期稳定C1-C2复合体可能潜在地预防SMO的进展。