Nath Charlotte, Schmidt Rebecca, Gunel Erdogan
West Virginia University School of Medicine, Department of Family Medicine, Robert C. Byrd Health Sciences Center, P.O. Box 9152, Morgantown, WV 26506-9152, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2006 Aug;70(8):825-34.
The purpose of this study was to assess whether the perception of what constitutes professionalism varies with age, discipline, gender, or educational level among students and faculty at the major academic health sciences center in West Virginia. This exploratory descriptive survey study asked participants to classify behaviors described in a survey as professional, unprofessional, or unrelated to professionalism. Results were analyzed using contingency tables. For 2 x 2 contingency tables, test of independence of homogeneity was carried out by using Fisher's exact test. For tables of higher dimensions, chi square test was used. The survey yielded a 45 percent return rate and demonstrated that the perception of professionalism varied most with the level of education and age and, to a lesser extent, with gender and health care discipline. Undergraduates, females, the youngest age group (< or = 26), nursing students, and faculty other than dental or medical were more likely to label behavior depicted in the survey statements as unprofessional. The findings of this study underscore the complexities of the genesis of professionalism. Further study in regard to the teaching of professionalism is warranted.
本研究的目的是评估在西弗吉尼亚州主要学术健康科学中心的学生和教员中,对于专业素养构成要素的认知是否因年龄、学科、性别或教育水平而异。这项探索性描述性调查研究要求参与者将调查中描述的行为归类为专业、不专业或与专业素养无关。使用列联表对结果进行分析。对于2×2列联表,采用费舍尔精确检验进行同质性独立性检验。对于更高维度的表格,使用卡方检验。该调查的回复率为45%,结果表明,对专业素养的认知在很大程度上随教育水平和年龄而变化,在较小程度上随性别和医疗保健学科而变化。本科生、女性、最年轻年龄组(≤26岁)、护理专业学生以及牙科或医学以外的教员更有可能将调查陈述中描述的行为标记为不专业。本研究结果强调了专业素养形成过程的复杂性。有必要对专业素养的教学进行进一步研究。