Houssami Nehmat, Sainsbury Richard
Screening and Test Evaluation Program (STEP), School of Public Health, A27, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
Eur J Cancer. 2006 Oct;42(15):2480-91. doi: 10.1016/j.ejca.2006.05.023. Epub 2006 Aug 10.
A multidisciplinary approach to the management of breast cancer is the standard of care in developed health systems. We performed a systematic review to assess the extent and quality of evidence on whether multidisciplinary care (MDC), or related aspects of care contribute to clinical outcomes in breast cancer, and in particular whether these influence survival. Only two primary studies have looked at MDC and neither of these studies considered long-term outcomes. The studies of MDC (case series) provide weak evidence that MDC may alter treatment patterns. Several population-based cohort studies showed that related aspects of team work, specialist (surgeon) and hospital workload and specialisation, are associated with improved survival. This group of studies used better quality design with more clearly defined outcome measures, and most of the studies have allowed for possible confounding variables. Evidence of a survival benefit was most consistent for specialist (surgeon) effect. However, the reasons behind the improved survival reported in these studies are unclear, and it is unlikely that this is entirely attributable to treatment patterns. We conclude that although intrinsically multidisciplinary care should be associated with better survival, there remains a paucity of evidence to support this. Studies of the long-term clinical effects of MDC in breast cancer should be a priority for future evaluation.
在发达的医疗体系中,采用多学科方法管理乳腺癌是治疗的标准。我们进行了一项系统综述,以评估关于多学科护理(MDC)或护理相关方面是否有助于改善乳腺癌临床结局,特别是这些因素是否影响生存率的证据的范围和质量。仅有两项初步研究关注了MDC,但这两项研究均未考虑长期结局。关于MDC的研究(病例系列)提供了薄弱的证据,表明MDC可能会改变治疗模式。几项基于人群的队列研究表明,团队合作、专科医生(外科医生)以及医院工作量和专科化等相关方面与生存率提高相关。这组研究采用了质量更高的设计,结局指标定义更明确,并且大多数研究都考虑到了可能的混杂变量。生存获益的证据在专科医生(外科医生)效应方面最为一致。然而,这些研究中报告的生存率提高背后的原因尚不清楚,而且这不太可能完全归因于治疗模式。我们得出结论,尽管本质上多学科护理应该与更好的生存率相关,但仍然缺乏支持这一点的证据。对乳腺癌中MDC的长期临床效果进行研究应作为未来评估的重点。