Waterson E, Harms E, Qupe L, Maritz J, Manning M, Makobe K, Chabeli M
Ann Latsky Nursing College.
Curationis. 2006 May;29(2):56-65. doi: 10.4102/curationis.v29i2.1077.
The aim of this contextual, exploratory, descriptive and qualitative study was to describe strategies to improve the performance of learners in a nursing college. The article seeks to deal with factors relating to nursing education that contribute to the poor performance of learners and to outline related strategies to improve the situation. Three focus group interviews were conducted. One group was formed by seven tutors, and the other two groups were formed by fourth-year learners following a four-year comprehensive diploma course. All participants voluntarily took part in the study. Data was analyzed using the descriptive method of open coding by Tesch (in Creswell, 1994:154-156). Trustworthiness was ensured in accordance with Lincoln and Guba's (1985:290-326) principles of credibility, conformability, transferability and dependability. The findings were categorized into issues pertaining to nursing education as follows: curriculum overload; lack of theory and practice integration; teaching and assessment methods that do not promote critical thinking; tutors' lack of skills and experience; inadequate preparation of tutors for lectures; insufficient knowledge of tutors regarding outcomes-based education approach to teaching and learning; inadequate process of remedial teaching; discrepancies between tutors' marking; lack of clinical role-models and high expectations from the affiliated university as regards standards of nursing development programme by the staff development committee of the nursing college under study for implementation. Future research should focus on the effectiveness of the described strategies to improve the learners' performance. It is also recommended that similar studies be conducted or replicated in other nursing colleges to address the problem of poor performance of learners engaged in a four-year comprehensive diploma course.
这项情境式、探索性、描述性和定性研究的目的是描述提高护理学院学生表现的策略。本文旨在探讨与护理教育相关的因素,这些因素导致学生表现不佳,并概述改善这种情况的相关策略。进行了三次焦点小组访谈。一组由七名导师组成,另外两组由参加四年制综合文凭课程的四年级学生组成。所有参与者均自愿参加该研究。数据采用特施(在克雷斯韦尔,1994:154 - 156)的开放式编码描述性方法进行分析。根据林肯和古巴(1985:290 - 326)的可信度、一致性、可转移性和可靠性原则确保了研究的可信度。研究结果被归类为与护理教育相关的问题如下:课程负担过重;理论与实践缺乏整合;不促进批判性思维的教学和评估方法;导师缺乏技能和经验;导师备课不足;导师对基于成果的教育教学方法的知识不足;补救教学过程不充分;导师评分存在差异;缺乏临床榜样以及附属大学对正在研究的护理学院员工发展委员会实施的护理发展计划标准期望过高。未来的研究应关注所描述策略提高学生表现的有效性。还建议在其他护理学院进行类似研究或重复研究,以解决参加四年制综合文凭课程的学生表现不佳的问题。