Sakamoto Yoshihiro, Kosuge Tomoo, Shimada Kazuaki, Sano Tsuyoshi, Hibi Taizo, Yamamoto Junji, Takayama Tadatoshi, Makuuchi Masatoshi
Hepatobiliary and Pancreatic Surgery Division, National Cancer Center Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
J Surg Oncol. 2006 Sep 15;94(4):298-306. doi: 10.1002/jso.20585.
The aim of this study was to determine the clinical significance of extrahepatic bile duct (EHBD) resection during surgery for advanced gallbladder cancer.
Among 110 patients with pT2 or higher grade gallbladder cancer, 58 patients without microscopic invasion to the EHBD were reviewed. Prognostic factors of the 58 patients were evaluated by multivariate analysis. The impact of EHBD resection on survival was assessed in relation to two prognostic determinants: (i) lymph node metastasis: positive (n = 23) and negative (n = 35); (ii) perineural invasion: positive (n = 25) and negative (n = 33).
Hepatic metastasis and perineural invasion were found to be independently significant prognostic factors. (i) No survival benefit of additional EHBD resection could be confirmed in each group of patients with or without nodal metastasis. (ii) In 25 patients with perineural invasion, 14 patients who underwent EHBD resection showed better survival as compared to the 11 patients who did not undergo EHBD resection (5-year survival rate, 46% vs. 0%, P = 0.009). In the remaining 33 patients without perineural invasion, the additional EHBD resection did not yield significant improvement of survival (P = 0.28).
Resection of EHBD may offer prognostic advantage when perineural invasion exists, even in the absence of biliary infiltration.
本研究旨在确定晚期胆囊癌手术中肝外胆管(EHBD)切除的临床意义。
在110例pT2或更高分期的胆囊癌患者中,回顾了58例无显微镜下肝外胆管侵犯的患者。通过多因素分析评估这58例患者的预后因素。根据两个预后决定因素评估肝外胆管切除对生存的影响:(i)淋巴结转移:阳性(n = 23)和阴性(n = 35);(ii)神经周围侵犯:阳性(n = 25)和阴性(n = 33)。
肝转移和神经周围侵犯被发现是独立的显著预后因素。(i)在有或无淋巴结转移的每组患者中,均未证实额外的肝外胆管切除有生存获益。(ii)在25例有神经周围侵犯的患者中,14例行肝外胆管切除的患者与11例未行肝外胆管切除的患者相比,生存情况更好(5年生存率,46%对0%,P = 0.009)。在其余33例无神经周围侵犯的患者中,额外的肝外胆管切除未带来生存的显著改善(P = 0.28)。
即使在没有胆管浸润的情况下,当存在神经周围侵犯时,肝外胆管切除可能具有预后优势。