Cravero Joseph P, Blike George T, Beach Michael, Gallagher Susan M, Hertzog James H, Havidich Jeana E, Gelman Barry
Department of Anesthesiology, Dartmouth Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, New Hampshire 03756, USA.
Pediatrics. 2006 Sep;118(3):1087-96. doi: 10.1542/peds.2006-0313.
We sought to use a large database of prospectively collected data on pediatric sedation and/or anesthesia for diagnostic and therapeutic procedures to delineate the nature and the frequency of adverse events that are associated with sedation/anesthesia care for procedures that are performed outside the operating room in children.
Data were collected by the Pediatric Sedation Research Consortium, a collaborative group of 35 institutions that are dedicated to improving sedation/anesthesia care for children internationally. Members prospectively enrolled consecutive patients who were receiving sedation or anesthesia for procedures. Data on demographics, primary illness, coexisting illness, procedure performed, medications used, outcomes, airway interventions, and adverse events were collected and reported on a Web-based data collection tool.
A total of 26 institutions submitted data on 30,037 sedation/anesthesia encounters during the study period from July 1, 2004, to November 15, 2005. Serious adverse events were rare in the institutions involved in this study; there were no deaths. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation was required once. Less serious events were more common with O2 desaturation below 90% for > 30 seconds, occurring 157 times per 10000 sedations. Stridor and laryngospasm both occurred in 4.3 per 10,000 sedations. Unexpected apnea, excessive secretions, and vomiting had frequencies of 24, 41.6, and 47.2 per 10,000 encounters, respectively.
Our data indicate that pediatric sedation/anesthesia for procedures outside the operating room is unlikely to yield serious adverse outcomes in a collection of institutions with highly motivated and organized sedation services. However, the safety of this practice depends on the systems' ability to manage less serious events.
我们试图利用一个前瞻性收集的关于儿科镇静和/或麻醉用于诊断和治疗程序的大型数据库,来描绘与儿童在手术室以外进行的程序的镇静/麻醉护理相关的不良事件的性质和频率。
数据由儿科镇静研究联盟收集,该联盟是一个由35个机构组成的合作组织,致力于在国际上改善儿童的镇静/麻醉护理。成员前瞻性地纳入接受程序镇静或麻醉的连续患者。收集了关于人口统计学、原发性疾病、并存疾病、进行的程序、使用的药物、结果、气道干预和不良事件的数据,并通过基于网络的数据收集工具进行报告。
在2004年7月1日至2005年11月15日的研究期间,共有26个机构提交了30037次镇静/麻醉记录的数据。在参与本研究的机构中,严重不良事件很少见;没有死亡病例。需要进行一次心肺复苏。不太严重的事件更常见的是氧饱和度低于90%超过30秒,每10000次镇静发生157次。喘鸣和喉痉挛每10000次镇静均发生4.3次。意外呼吸暂停、分泌物过多和呕吐的发生率分别为每10000次记录24次、41.6次和47.2次。
我们的数据表明,在拥有积极性高且组织有序的镇静服务的机构中,儿科在手术室以外进行程序的镇静/麻醉不太可能产生严重不良后果。然而,这种做法的安全性取决于系统管理不太严重事件的能力。