Bishop Sonia J, Jenkins Rob, Lawrence Andrew D
MRC/Wellcome Trust Behavioural & Clinical Neuroscience Institute, Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 3EB, UK.
Cereb Cortex. 2007 Jul;17(7):1595-603. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhl070. Epub 2006 Sep 6.
Debate continues as to the automaticity of the amygdala's response to threat. Accounts taking a strong automaticity line suggest that the amygdala's response to threat is both involuntary and independent of attentional resources. Building on these accounts, prominent models have suggested that anxiety modulates the output of an amygdala-based preattentive threat evaluation system. Here, we argue for a modification of these models. Functional magnetic resonance imaging data were collected while volunteers performed a letter search task of high or low perceptual load superimposed on fearful or neutral face distractors. Neither high- nor low-anxious volunteers showed an increased amygdala response to threat distractors under high perceptual load, contrary to a strong automaticity account of amygdala function. Under low perceptual load, elevated state anxiety was associated with a heightened response to threat distractors in the amygdala and superior temporal sulcus, whereas individuals high in trait anxiety showed a reduced prefrontal response to these stimuli, consistent with weakened recruitment of control mechanisms used to prevent the further processing of salient distractors. These findings suggest that anxiety modulates processing subsequent to competition for perceptual processing resources, with state and trait anxiety having distinguishable influences upon the neural mechanisms underlying threat evaluation and "top-down" control.
关于杏仁核对威胁的反应是否具有自动性,争论仍在继续。持强烈自动性观点的说法认为,杏仁核对威胁的反应既是不由自主的,又独立于注意力资源。基于这些说法,一些著名的模型提出,焦虑会调节基于杏仁核的前注意威胁评估系统的输出。在此,我们主张对这些模型进行修正。在志愿者执行叠加有恐惧或中性面部干扰物的高或低感知负荷字母搜索任务时,收集了功能磁共振成像数据。与杏仁核功能的强烈自动性观点相反,无论是高焦虑还是低焦虑的志愿者在高感知负荷下,杏仁核对威胁干扰物的反应都没有增加。在低感知负荷下,状态焦虑的升高与杏仁核和颞上沟对威胁干扰物的反应增强有关,而特质焦虑高的个体对这些刺激的前额叶反应减弱,这与用于防止对显著干扰物进行进一步加工的控制机制的募集减弱一致。这些发现表明,焦虑在争夺感知加工资源之后调节加工过程,状态焦虑和特质焦虑对威胁评估和“自上而下”控制的神经机制有不同的影响。