DeKeyser Ganz Freda, Kahana Shulamit
Hadassah Hebrew University School of Nursing, Jerusalem, Israel.
J Adv Nurs. 2006 Oct;56(1):88-98. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2006.03983.x.
This paper reports a study to determine the perceptions of baccalaureate nursing students towards clinical specialties and what factors influenced these perceptions.
Previous studies have shown that nursing students enter their professional education with preconceived perceptions about the different clinical specialties in nursing. Some investigators have found that factors such as clinical experience influence these perceptions, but others have not. Cultural and social influences, especially among non-western cultures, have rarely been investigated.
Israeli baccalaureate nursing students were surveyed in their first, third and fourth years of study during the years 1998-2004. They were asked to rank their preferences for clinical areas related to social need, social prestige, level of interest in the clinical area, job choice and what factors influenced their decisions related to job choice. Mean ranks and associations between class and calendar year cohorts were calculated.
Critical care was consistently ranked as the highest preference in all perception checklists, followed by emergency, maternity and paediatric nursing. Psychiatric, community and gerontological nursing were consistently found at the bottom of the list. High levels of association were found among students from different class cohorts and calendar years. Life experiences were ranked as the factor that most influenced career choice.
Nursing students in Israel tend to perceive clinical areas in ways similar to other students around the world. These perceptions are strongly influenced by personal experiences and other personal contacts, most often not nursing instructors. Major changes in the local society seem for the most part to have little impact on these perceptions. Therefore there is a need for international nurse educators and recruiters to develop new, creative strategies to encourage nursing students to pursue careers in areas presently considered less popular.
本文报告一项研究,以确定护理学本科学生对临床专业的看法以及哪些因素影响了这些看法。
先前的研究表明,护理专业学生在进入专业教育时,对护理领域的不同临床专业已有先入为主的看法。一些研究者发现,诸如临床经验等因素会影响这些看法,但其他研究者则未发现此现象。文化和社会影响,尤其是非西方文化中的影响,很少受到调查。
对1998年至2004年期间以色列护理学本科学生在其学习的第一年、第三年和第四年进行了调查。要求他们对与社会需求、社会声望、对临床领域的兴趣程度、职业选择相关的临床领域进行偏好排序,以及哪些因素影响了他们与职业选择相关的决定。计算了不同班级和学年队列之间的平均排名及关联。
在所有认知清单中,重症监护一直被列为最高偏好,其次是急诊、产科和儿科护理。精神科、社区和老年护理一直排在清单末尾。在不同班级队列和学年的学生中发现了高度关联。生活经历被列为对职业选择影响最大的因素。
以色列的护理专业学生对临床领域的看法往往与世界其他学生相似。这些看法受到个人经历和其他个人接触的强烈影响,这些接触大多不是护理教师。当地社会的重大变化在很大程度上似乎对这些看法影响不大。因此,国际护理教育工作者和招聘人员需要制定新的、有创意的策略,以鼓励护理专业学生从事目前被认为不太受欢迎领域的职业。