Handwerk Michael L, Clopton Kerri, Huefner Jonathan C, Smith Gail L, Hoff Kathy E, Lucas Christopher P
Clinical Services and Research, Girls and Boys Town, Boys Town, NE 68010, USA.
Am J Orthopsychiatry. 2006 Jul;76(3):312-24. doi: 10.1037/0002-9432.76.3.312.
Gender differences for adolescents in residential care were examined for a sample of 2,067 youths in a large residential facility. At admission, female youths were more troubled than male youths, as shown in significantly higher Diagnostic Interview Schedule for Children (DISC) diagnoses and comorbidity rates, higher internalizing and externalizing Child Behavior Checklist scores, and significantly higher Suicide Prevention Scale hopelessness, negative self-evaluation, and suicide ideation scores. Girls had higher rates of depressive and anxiety diagnoses on the DISC at both admission and 1 year. Both genders demonstrated significant reductions in both externalizing and internalizing problem behaviors over the first year in the program. Girls had significantly higher rates of internalizing problem behavior but showed a significantly greater reduction in these behaviors than did boys. At departure, girls were rated as being more successful than boys by clinical staff. Youths did not differ by gender in their behavior on a 6-month follow-up success scale. Implications for prioritizing research addressing the needs of female adolescents in residential care are discussed.
对一家大型寄宿机构中2067名青少年样本进行了寄宿照料中青少年性别差异的研究。入院时,女性青少年比男性青少年问题更多,表现为儿童诊断访谈量表(DISC)诊断和共病率显著更高、儿童行为检查表内化和外化得分更高,以及自杀预防量表中绝望感、负面自我评价和自杀意念得分显著更高。女孩在入院时和1年后的DISC上抑郁和焦虑诊断率更高。在项目的第一年,两性的外化和内化问题行为都有显著减少。女孩内化问题行为的发生率显著更高,但这些行为的减少幅度比男孩显著更大。出院时,临床工作人员对女孩的评价比男孩更成功。在6个月的随访成功量表上,青少年的行为不存在性别差异。讨论了优先开展研究以满足寄宿照料中女性青少年需求的意义。