Wren Jonathan D, Johnson Kathryn R, Crockett David M, Heilig Lauren F, Schilling Lisa M, Dellavalle Robert P
Department of Botany and Microbiology, Advanced Center for Genome Technology, University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK, USA.
Arch Dermatol. 2006 Sep;142(9):1147-52. doi: 10.1001/archderm.142.9.1147.
To describe dermatology journal uniform resource locator (URL) use and persistence and to better understand the level of control and awareness of authors regarding the availability of the URLs they cite.
Software was written to automatically access URLs in articles published between January 1, 1999, and September 30, 2004, in the 3 dermatology journals with the highest scientific impact. Authors of publications with unavailable URLs were surveyed regarding URL content, availability, and preservation.
Uniform resource locator use and persistence and author opinions and practices.
The percentage of articles containing at least 1 URL increased from 2.3% in 1999 to 13.5% in 2004. Of the 1113 URLs, 81.7% were available (decreasing with time since publication from 89.1% of 2004 URLs to 65.4% of 1999 URLs) (P<.001). Uniform resource locator unavailability was highest in The Journal of Investigative Dermatology (22.1%) and lowest in the Archives of Dermatology (14.8%) (P=.03). Some content was partially recoverable via the Internet Archive for 120 of the 204 unavailable URLs. Most authors (55.2%) agreed that the unavailable URL content was important to the publication, but few controlled URL availability personally (5%) or with the help of others (employees, colleagues, and friends) (6.7%).
Uniform resource locators are increasingly used and lost in dermatology journals. Loss will continue until better preservation policies are adopted.
描述皮肤科期刊统一资源定位符(URL)的使用情况和持久性,并更好地了解作者对其所引用URL可用性的控制水平和认知程度。
编写软件自动访问1999年1月1日至2004年9月30日期间发表在3种具有最高科学影响力的皮肤科期刊上的文章中的URL。对URL不可用的出版物的作者就URL内容、可用性和保存情况进行了调查。
统一资源定位符的使用情况、持久性以及作者的意见和做法。
包含至少1个URL的文章比例从1999年的2.3%增至2004年的13.5%。在1113个URL中,81.7%可用(自发表以来随时间推移从2004年URL的89.1%降至1999年URL的65.4%)(P<0.001)。《皮肤病学研究杂志》中URL不可用的比例最高(22.1%),而《皮肤病学文献》中最低(14.8%)(P=0.03)。对于204个不可用的URL中的120个,部分内容可通过互联网档案馆找回。大多数作者(55.2%)认为不可用的URL内容对出版物很重要,但很少有人亲自控制URL的可用性(5%)或在他人(员工、同事和朋友)帮助下控制(6.7%)。
统一资源定位符在皮肤科期刊中的使用越来越多,但丢失情况也日益严重。在采用更好的保存政策之前,丢失情况将持续存在。