Baughcum Amy E, Gerhardt Cynthia A, Young-Saleme Tammi, Stefanik Regina, Klopfenstein Kathryn J
Center for Biobehavioral Health, Columbus Children's Research Institute, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA.
Pediatr Blood Cancer. 2007 Aug;49(2):154-9. doi: 10.1002/pbc.21034.
Recent efforts have focused on improving pediatric palliative care to relieve physical and psychological suffering throughout the course of illness, as well as to improve care at the end-of-life (EOL). One area of attention has been medical training, as healthcare providers have often reported feeling ill-equipped to manage EOL issues. As a pilot study, we developed and evaluated a daylong educational workshop on pediatric palliative care for oncology fellows.
Fellows (N = 32) from 20 hospitals participated in one of two workshops covering palliative care topics, such as pain/symptom management, communication, ethics, and bereavement. Training, knowledge, behavior, and attitudes regarding pediatric palliative care were assessed before the workshop, and knowledge was re-assessed immediately afterwards.
Fellows reported a general lack of training in EOL care, and only 41% rated their education as at least "somewhat" adequate. Colleagues and personal experience were more often sources on EOL care, rather than formal classes or textbooks. Although fellows reported open attitudes toward palliative care, such as involving adolescents in decision-making, only half felt comfortable in the presence of a dying person. Fewer than half felt comfortable providing EOL care, managing families' expectations, or knowledgeable enough to discuss hospice with patients/families. Following the workshop, knowledge of palliative care increased significantly from 75 to 85% correct.
Fellows reported open beliefs about palliative care, but acknowledged weaknesses in their training and level of competence. The workshop showed efficacy in improving knowledge, but additional research is needed to evaluate larger educational initiatives and their long-term impact on clinical services and family satisfaction.
近期的努力聚焦于改善儿科姑息治疗,以缓解疾病全过程中的身体和心理痛苦,同时改善临终关怀。关注的一个领域是医学培训,因为医疗服务提供者经常报告感觉自己在处理临终问题方面准备不足。作为一项试点研究,我们为肿瘤学研究员开发并评估了一个为期一天的儿科姑息治疗教育工作坊。
来自20家医院的研究员(N = 32)参加了两个涵盖姑息治疗主题的工作坊之一,这些主题包括疼痛/症状管理、沟通、伦理和丧亲之痛。在工作坊前评估了关于儿科姑息治疗的培训、知识、行为和态度,并在工作坊结束后立即重新评估了知识。
研究员报告称在临终关怀方面普遍缺乏培训,只有41%的人认为他们的教育至少“有点”充分。同事和个人经验更多地是临终关怀的来源,而不是正规课程或教科书。尽管研究员报告对姑息治疗持开放态度,比如让青少年参与决策,但只有一半的人在有垂危病人在场时感到自在。不到一半的人在提供临终关怀、管理家庭期望或有足够知识与患者/家庭讨论临终关怀方面感到自在。工作坊结束后,姑息治疗知识的正确率从75%显著提高到了85%。
研究员报告对姑息治疗持开放信念,但承认他们在培训和能力水平方面存在不足。该工作坊在提高知识方面显示出了效果,但需要更多研究来评估更大规模的教育举措及其对临床服务和家庭满意度的长期影响。