Gift Thomas L, Lincoln Thomas, Tuthill Robert, Whelan Michael, Briggs L Patricia, Conklin Thomas, Irwin Kathleen L
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia 30333, USA.
Sex Transm Dis. 2006 Oct;33(10 Suppl):S103-10. doi: 10.1097/01.olq.0000235169.45680.7c.
Few cost-effectiveness evaluations of screening men in jails for chlamydia have been published, and none have evaluated the cost-effectiveness of providing partner notification services to the partners of chlamydia-infected inmates.
The goal of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the chlamydia screening and partner notification programs for men conducted by a Massachusetts jail compared with 3 hypothetical alternatives.
Using jail cost and testing data, we used decision analyses to compare the cost and effectiveness of universal screening, age-based screening with 2 age cutoffs, and testing of symptomatic inmates at intake using treated cases of chlamydia and gonorrhea as the primary outcome. We also evaluated the cost-effectiveness of adding partner notification to these alternatives.
Universal screening was the most effective and expensive alternative. Age-based screening would have identified slightly fewer cases at half the cost of universal screening. The net cost of partner notification was low. Assuming high sequelae costs in female partners made partner notification a cost-saving intervention.
Age-based screening could lower costs without substantially sacrificing effectiveness. Notifying partners of infected inmates was a cost-effective adjunct to screening inmates.
很少有关于监狱男性衣原体筛查成本效益评估的文献发表,且尚无研究评估为衣原体感染囚犯的性伴提供性伴通知服务的成本效益。
本研究的目的是评估马萨诸塞州一所监狱针对男性开展的衣原体筛查和性伴通知项目与三种假设替代方案相比的成本效益。
利用监狱成本和检测数据,我们采用决策分析方法,以衣原体和淋病的治疗病例作为主要结局,比较普遍筛查、采用两个年龄切点的年龄分层筛查以及对有症状囚犯入监时进行检测这三种方案的成本和效果。我们还评估了在这些替代方案基础上增加性伴通知的成本效益。
普遍筛查是最有效但成本最高的替代方案。年龄分层筛查发现的病例略少,但其成本仅为普遍筛查的一半。性伴通知的净成本较低。假设女性性伴的后遗症成本较高,性伴通知成为一种节省成本的干预措施。
年龄分层筛查可在不大幅牺牲效果的情况下降低成本。通知感染囚犯的性伴是筛查囚犯的一项具有成本效益的辅助措施。