Mourão-Miranda Janaina, Reynaud Emanuelle, McGlone Francis, Calvert Gemma, Brammer Michael
Biostatics Department, Centre for Neuroimaging Sciences, Institute of Psychiatry, KCL, London, UK.
Neuroimage. 2006 Dec;33(4):1055-65. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.08.016. Epub 2006 Sep 28.
In the present study, we compared the effects of temporal compression (averaging across multiple scans) and space selection (i.e. selection of "regions of interest" from the whole brain) on single-subject and multi-subject classification of fMRI data using the support vector machine (SVM). Our aim was to investigate various data transformations that could be applied before training the SVM to retain task discriminatory variance while suppressing irrelevant components of variance. The data were acquired during a blocked experiment design: viewing unpleasant (Class 1), neutral (Class 2) and pleasant pictures (Class 3). In the multi-subject level analysis, we used a "leave-one-subject-out" approach, i.e. in each iteration, we trained the SVM using data from all but one subject and tested its performance in predicting the class label of the this last subject's data. In the single-subject level analysis, we used a "leave-one-block-out" approach, i.e. for each subject, we selected randomly one block per condition to be the test block and trained the SVM using data from the remaining blocks. Our results showed that in a single-subject level both temporal compression and space selection improved the SVM accuracy. However, in a multi-subject level, the temporal compression improved the performance of the SVM, but the space selection had no effect on the classification accuracy.
在本研究中,我们使用支持向量机(SVM)比较了时间压缩(对多次扫描进行平均)和空间选择(即从全脑选择“感兴趣区域”)对功能磁共振成像(fMRI)数据单受试者和多受试者分类的影响。我们的目的是研究在训练SVM之前可以应用的各种数据变换,以保留任务判别方差,同时抑制无关的方差成分。数据是在一个组块实验设计中采集的:观看不愉快(类别1)、中性(类别2)和愉快的图片(类别3)。在多受试者水平分析中,我们使用了“留一受试者法”,即在每次迭代中,我们使用除一个受试者之外的所有受试者的数据训练SVM,并测试其预测最后一个受试者数据的类别标签的性能。在单受试者水平分析中,我们使用了“留一组块法”,即对于每个受试者,我们在每个条件下随机选择一个组块作为测试组块,并使用其余组块的数据训练SVM。我们的结果表明,在单受试者水平上,时间压缩和空间选择都提高了SVM的准确性。然而,在多受试者水平上,时间压缩提高了SVM的性能,但空间选择对分类准确性没有影响。