Neubert Antje, Dormann Harald, Weiss Jutta, Criegee-Rieck Manfred, Ackermann Andreas, Levy Micha, Brune Kay, Rascher Wolfgang
Department of Experimental and Clinical Pharmacology and Toxicology, Friedrich Alexander University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Fahrstrasse 17, 91054, Erlangen, Germany.
Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 2006 Nov;62(11):959-65. doi: 10.1007/s00228-006-0197-9. Epub 2006 Oct 5.
The aim of the present study was to evaluate a computerised monitoring system (CMS) based on laboratory test results for the detection of adverse drug reactions (ADRs) on a paediatric ward.
A prospective, 6-month pharmacoepidemiological survey was performed on a 22-bed paediatric isolation ward. ADRs were identified by intensive chart review. In addition to spontaneous reporting by the treating physician, automatic laboratory signals generated by a CMS were evaluated for their association with ADRs. ADRs were classified by the affected target organs according to the WHO-ART system organ classes.
A total of 73 ADRs were identified in 439 admissions (396 patients) by chart review. The CMS alerted 31 (42.4%) ADRs while 23 (31.5%) ADRs were found solely by treating physicians. Eight ADRs were detected by both approaches resulting in a total detection rate of 74% (compared with intensive pharmacovigilance). Out of a total of 27,434 laboratory tests performed routinely, 1,563 were classified as abnormal by the predefined CMS and used as the basis of alerts. The sensitivity of the system with respect to patients alerted was 90.3% and the specificity only 19.6%.
This study demonstrates that, using CMS, a different kind of mild adverse events were detected compared to the observation by the treating physician. The system presented appears to be sufficiently sensitive, but the specificity is too low to make it acceptable for physicians in daily practice. In children, clinically important ADRs can be detected best by intensified surveillance.
本研究旨在评估一种基于实验室检测结果的计算机化监测系统(CMS),用于检测儿科病房中的药物不良反应(ADR)。
在一个有22张床位的儿科隔离病房进行了一项为期6个月的前瞻性药物流行病学调查。通过深入的病历审查来识别ADR。除了治疗医生的自发报告外,还评估了CMS生成的自动实验室信号与ADR的相关性。根据世界卫生组织药物不良反应术语集(WHO-ART)系统器官分类,按受影响的靶器官对ADR进行分类。
通过病历审查,在439例入院患者(396名患者)中总共识别出73例ADR。CMS警报了31例(42.4%)ADR,而仅由治疗医生发现了23例(31.5%)ADR。两种方法均检测到8例ADR,总检测率为74%(与强化药物警戒相比)。在总共27434次常规进行的实验室检测中,有1563次被预定义的CMS分类为异常,并用作警报的依据。该系统对警报患者的敏感性为90.3%,特异性仅为19.6%。
本研究表明,与治疗医生的观察相比,使用CMS检测到了不同类型的轻度不良事件。所呈现的系统似乎具有足够的敏感性,但特异性太低,使其在日常实践中对医生来说不可接受。在儿童中,通过强化监测可以最好地检测出具有临床重要性的ADR。