Stommel Manfred, Olomu Ade, Holmes-Rovner Margaret, Corser William, Gardiner Joseph C
College of Nursing, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2006 Oct 24;6:140. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-6-140.
Adherence to clinical practice guidelines for the treatment of specific illnesses may result in unexpected outcomes, given that multiple therapies must often be given to patients with diverse medical conditions. Yet, few studies have presented empirical evidence that quality improvement (QI) programs both change practice by improving adherence to guidelines and improve patient outcomes under the conditions of actual practice. Thus, we focus on patient survival, following hospitalization for acute coronary syndrome in three successive patient cohorts from the same community hospitals, with a quality improvement intervention occurring between cohorts two and three.
This study is a comparison of three historical cohorts of Acute Coronary Syndrome (ACS) patients in the same five community hospitals in 1994-5, 1997, 2002-3. A quality improvement project, the Guidelines Applied to Practice (GAP), was implemented in these hospitals in 2001. Study participants were recruited from community hospitals located in two Michigan communities during three separate time periods. The cohorts comprise (1) patients enrolled between December 1993 and April 1995 (N = 814), (2) patients enrolled between February 1997 and September 1997 (N = 452), and (3) patients enrolled between January 14, 2002 and April 13, 2003 (N = 710). Mortality data were obtained from Michigan's Bureau of Vital Statistics for all three patient cohorts. Predictor variables, obtained from medical record reviews, included demographic information, indicators of disease severity (ejection fraction), co-morbid conditions, hospital treatment information concerning most invasive procedures and the use of ace-inhibitors, beta-blockers and aspirin in the hospital and as discharge recommendations.
Adjusted in-hospital mortality showed a marked improvement with a HR = 0.16 (p < 0.001) comparing 2003 patients in the same hospitals to those 10 years earlier. Large gains in the in-hospital mortality were maintained based on 1-year mortality rates after hospital discharge.
Changes in practice patterns that follow recommended guidelines can significantly improve care for ACS patients. In-hospital mortality gains were maintained in the year following discharge.
鉴于患有多种疾病的患者通常必须接受多种治疗,遵循特定疾病治疗的临床实践指南可能会产生意想不到的结果。然而,很少有研究提供实证证据表明质量改进(QI)项目既能通过提高对指南的遵循来改变实践,又能在实际实践条件下改善患者预后。因此,我们关注来自同一社区医院的三个连续患者队列急性冠状动脉综合征住院后的患者生存率,在队列二和队列三之间进行了质量改进干预。
本研究是对1994 - 1995年、1997年、2002 - 2003年在同一五家社区医院的三个急性冠状动脉综合征(ACS)患者历史队列的比较。2001年在这些医院实施了一个质量改进项目,即应用于实践的指南(GAP)。研究参与者在三个不同时间段从位于密歇根州两个社区的社区医院招募。队列包括:(1)1993年12月至1995年4月登记的患者(N = 814),(2)1997年2月至1997年9月登记的患者(N = 452),以及(3)2002年1月14日至2003年4月13日登记的患者(N = 710)。所有三个患者队列的死亡率数据均从密歇根州生命统计局获得。从病历审查中获得的预测变量包括人口统计学信息、疾病严重程度指标(射血分数)、合并症、关于大多数侵入性手术的医院治疗信息以及住院期间和出院建议中使用血管紧张素转换酶抑制剂、β受体阻滞剂和阿司匹林的情况。
与10年前同一医院的患者相比,调整后的住院死亡率有显著改善,HR = 0.16(p < 0.001)。基于出院后1年死亡率,住院死亡率保持了大幅下降。
遵循推荐指南的实践模式变化可显著改善ACS患者的护理。出院后一年内住院死亡率的改善得以维持。