Tang Nian-Sheng, Tang Man-Lai, Wang Shun-Fang
Department of Statistics, Yunnan University, Kunming 650091, China.
Biostatistics. 2007 Jul;8(3):625-31. doi: 10.1093/biostatistics/kxl034. Epub 2006 Oct 27.
In this article, we compare Wald-type, logarithmic transformation, and Fieller-type statistics for the classical 2-sided equivalence testing of the rate ratio under matched-pair designs with a binary end point. These statistics can be implemented through sample-based, constrained least squares estimation and constrained maximum likelihood (CML) estimation methods. Sample size formulae based on the CML estimation method are developed. We consider formulae that control a prespecified power or confidence width. Our simulation studies show that statistics based on the CML estimation method generally outperform other statistics and methods with respect to actual type I error rate and average width of confidence intervals. Also, the corresponding sample size formulae are valid asymptotically in the sense that the exact power and actual coverage probability for the estimated sample size are generally close to their prespecified values. The methods are illustrated with a real example from a clinical laboratory study.
在本文中,我们比较了用于具有二元终点的配对设计下率比的经典双侧等效性检验的 Wald 型、对数变换和 Fieller 型统计量。这些统计量可以通过基于样本的约束最小二乘估计和约束最大似然(CML)估计方法来实现。基于 CML 估计方法开发了样本量公式。我们考虑控制预先指定的功效或置信区间宽度的公式。我们的模拟研究表明,基于 CML 估计方法的统计量在实际 I 型错误率和置信区间平均宽度方面通常优于其他统计量和方法。此外,相应的样本量公式在渐近意义上是有效的,即估计样本量的精确功效和实际覆盖概率通常接近其预先指定的值。通过一项临床实验室研究的实际例子对这些方法进行了说明。