Tallarida Ronald J
Department of Pharmacology, and Center on Substance Research, Temple University School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA 19149, USA.
Pharmacol Ther. 2007 Jan;113(1):197-209. doi: 10.1016/j.pharmthera.2006.08.002. Epub 2006 Sep 7.
This review has 2 parts. Part I deals with isobolographic procedures that are traditionally applied to the joint action of agonists that individually produce overtly similar effects. Special attention is directed to newer computational procedures that apply to agonists with dissimilar concentration-effect curves. These newer procedures are consistent with the isobolographic methods introduced and used by Loewe, however, the present communications provides the needed graphical and mathematical detail. A major aim is distinguishing super and sub-addictive interactions from those that are simply additive. The detection and measurement of an interaction is an important step in exploring drug mechanism and is also important clinically. Part II discusses a new use of isoboles that is applicable to a single drug or chemical whose effect is mediated by 2 or more receptor subtypes. This application produces a metric that characterizes the interaction between the receptor subtypes. The expansion of traditional isobolographic theory to this multi-receptor situation follows from the newer approaches for 2-drug combination analysis in Part I. This topic leads naturally to a re-examination of competitive antagonism and the classic Schild plot. In particular, it is shown here that the Schild plot in the multi-receptor case is not necessarily linear with unit slope. Both parts of this review emphasize the quantitative aspects rather than the many drugs that have been analyzed with isobolographic methods. The mathematical exposition is rather elementary and is further aided by several graphs. An appendix is included for the reader interested in the mathematical details.
本综述分为两部分。第一部分讨论等效线图法,该方法传统上应用于单独产生明显相似效应的激动剂的联合作用。特别关注适用于具有不同浓度 - 效应曲线的激动剂的新计算方法。这些新方法与洛伊引入和使用的等效线图法一致,然而,本通讯提供了所需的图形和数学细节。一个主要目的是区分超相加和亚相加相互作用与简单相加的相互作用。相互作用的检测和测量是探索药物作用机制的重要一步,在临床上也很重要。第二部分讨论等效线的一种新用途,它适用于其效应由两种或更多种受体亚型介导的单一药物或化学物质。这种应用产生了一种表征受体亚型之间相互作用的指标。将传统等效线图理论扩展到这种多受体情况是基于第一部分中二维药物组合分析的新方法。这个主题自然地引出了对竞争性拮抗作用和经典希尔德图的重新审视。特别是,这里表明在多受体情况下希尔德图不一定具有单位斜率的线性关系。本综述的两部分都强调定量方面,而不是用等效线图法分析的众多药物。数学阐述相当基础,并辅以几幅图表。附录为对数学细节感兴趣的读者而设。