Lau S K, Wei W I, Van Hasselt C A, Sham C L, Woo J, Choa D, Engzell U C
Department of Surgery, University of Hong Kong.
Asian Pac J Allergy Immunol. 1990 Dec;8(2):109-15.
The efficacy of budesonide, terfenadine and a combination of budesonide and oxymetazoline in the treatment of perennial rhinitis was evaluated by a double blind, parallel group study. Adult patients with perennial rhinitis were randomized into three groups. Group 1 patients received budesonide nasal aerosol 400 micrograms/day for 21 days and oxymetazoline nasal drops for the first three days. Group 2 and 3 patients received budesonide 400 micrograms/day and terfenadne tablet 60 mg twice/day respectively. Nasal symptoms were assessed by the patients before and daily during the treatment period using a simple scoring system. One hundred and forty-two patients were recruited and 130 completed the study. Budesonide, but not terfenadine, significantly reduced all nasal symptoms from baseline (p less than 0.05). Terfenadine could significantly relieve the nasal blockage (p less than 0.05) more than other nasal symptoms. Budesonide with or without oxymetazoline nasal drops provided a better control of nasal symptoms than terfenadine (p less than 0.05). Budesonide with oxymetazoline for the first three days showed a faster relief of nasal blockage than budesonide alone (p less than 0.05). Mild and transient adverse effects were encountered in all three groups. It is concluded that nasal symptoms of perennial rhinitis are more adequately controlled by budesonide than by terfenadine.
通过一项双盲、平行组研究评估了布地奈德、特非那定以及布地奈德与羟甲唑啉联合用药治疗常年性鼻炎的疗效。成年常年性鼻炎患者被随机分为三组。第1组患者接受布地奈德鼻气雾剂,每日400微克,共21天,前三天加用羟甲唑啉滴鼻剂。第2组和第3组患者分别接受每日400微克布地奈德和每日两次、每次60毫克特非那定片治疗。在治疗期间,患者在治疗前及每天使用简单评分系统评估鼻部症状。共招募了142例患者,130例完成了研究。布地奈德可显著减轻所有鼻部症状,较基线水平有改善(p<0.05),而特非那定无此效果。特非那定能显著缓解鼻塞(p<0.05),效果优于其他鼻部症状。布地奈德无论是否联用羟甲唑啉滴鼻剂,对鼻部症状的控制均优于特非那定(p<0.05)。前三天联用布地奈德和羟甲唑啉,鼻塞缓解速度比单用布地奈德更快(p<0.05)。三组均出现了轻微且短暂的不良反应。得出的结论是,布地奈德对常年性鼻炎鼻部症状的控制优于特非那定。