Drickamer Margaret A, Levy Becca, Irwin Kevin S, Rohrbaugh Robert M
Department of Internal Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06504, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2006 Dec;21(12):1230-4. doi: 10.1111/j.1525-1497.2006.00585.x.
Traditional methods of setting curricular guidelines using experts or consensus panels may miss important areas of knowledge, skills, and attitudes that need to be addressed in the training of medical students and residents.
To seek input from medical students and internal medicine residents ("trainees") on their perception of their needs for training in Geriatrics.
Two assessment methods were used (1) focus groups with students and residents were conducted by professional facilitators and the transcripts analyzed for areas of agreement and divergence and (2) geriatric medicine experts and ward attendings were surveyed to examine training gaps raised by trainees during Geriatric Guest Attending Rounds.
Trainees perceived training gaps in caring for elderly patients in the areas of (1) recognizing and addressing the complex, multifactorial nature of illness; (2) setting priorities and goals for work-up and intervention; (3) communication with families and with patients with cognitive disorders; (4) assessment of a patient for discharge from the hospital and the services at different sites in which patients may receive care. They recounted feeling overwhelmed by complex patients and social situations while acknowledging the special aspects of connecting with older patients. The gaps identified by trainees differ from and complement the curriculum guidelines set by expert recommendations.
Trainees identified gaps in skills and knowledge leading to trainee frustration and potentially adverse outcomes in caring for elderly patients. Development of curriculum guidelines should include assessment of trainees' perceived learning needs.
使用专家或共识小组制定课程指南的传统方法可能会遗漏医学生和住院医师培训中需要涵盖的重要知识、技能和态度领域。
征求医学生和内科住院医师(“学员”)对老年医学培训需求的看法。
采用了两种评估方法:(1)由专业主持人组织学生和住院医师进行焦点小组讨论,并对记录进行分析,以找出一致和分歧的领域;(2)对老年医学专家和病房主治医师进行调查,以检查学员在老年客座主治医师查房期间提出的培训差距。
学员们意识到在照顾老年患者方面存在培训差距,这些差距体现在以下方面:(1)认识并应对疾病的复杂、多因素性质;(2)确定检查和干预的优先事项和目标;(3)与患者家属和认知障碍患者沟通;(4)评估患者出院情况以及患者可能接受护理的不同地点的服务。他们表示面对复杂的患者和社会情况感到不知所措,同时也承认与老年患者沟通有其特殊之处。学员们指出的差距与专家建议制定的课程指南不同且互为补充。
学员们指出了技能和知识方面的差距,这些差距导致学员在照顾老年患者时感到沮丧,并可能产生不良后果。课程指南的制定应包括对学员感知到的学习需求的评估。